Characteristics of research into professional learning across professions: A mapping review

Abstract

Given the importance of their roles in society, the education of professionals is a central concern for providers and recipients of public services. In this article we consider the contribution of research on professional learning to current debate on the form and content of professional education. This mapping review asked, ‘What does the research literature tell us about the characteristics of research into professional learning across professions?’ We identified and synthesised primary research involving post‐qualification professionals' professional learning. We searched seven databases using terms such as ‘professional learning’, ‘professional development’ and ‘continuing education’ from 2000 to date. We carefully screened articles against agreed criteria, extracted data and mapped the findings. After removing duplicates, 20,616 records remained. After full text screening, 356 articles were included: 266 from teaching (75%), 77 from healthcare (22%) and 13 from another profession or cross‐professional (4%). Three included papers that spanned professions. Only 6% of articles studied the institution as the unit of analysis (rather than the individual). Around half of the included papers (49%) included an intervention. Most teaching interventions were proximal to the workplace whereas most healthcare/other studies were distal to the workplace, perhaps reflecting stage of development of the research field. Our study synthesised a heterogeneous literature to indicate the types or research that are needed to progress the debate. The clear differences in ‘style’ between professions suggested that collaboration could provide mutual benefit. Future research requires studies that report research in ways that lend themselves to evidence synthesis or replication.

Enhancing emotional health and engagement in Chinese English language learners: an approach from teachers’ autonomy- supportive behavior, teachers’ harmony, and peer support in a two-sample study

“…At the same time, potential influence of Teachers’ psychological Harmony, not only on their own wellbeing, but also on students’ outcomes, agreed with previous findings and suggestions ( Tharp et al, 2018 ; Uwayid and Jabbar, 2023 ). In this vein, some professional development initiatives are proposed for increasing Teachers’ harmony that could, in turn, have an impact on learners’ ( Hadar and Brody, 2010 ; Baumfield et al, 2023 ; Wang and Zou, 2023 ).…”

Vol. 14 No. 1 (2024)

“…The Australian Council of Professions provided an agreed definition of professions, in which expert knowledge is combined with trustworthiness (Baumfield et al, 2023). The legitimacy of who can perform the work and what is needed to perform and evaluate it ) may be strengthened based on two central sources: the profession's knowledge that adapts to new niches following changes in the workplace , and having the trustworthiness of the public-partners in its character.…”

“…These elements need to be further studied by examining perceptions as well as behavioral interactions in various contexts. We should understand the processes of learning the core, both through formal programs and informal workplace interactions and at various career stages (Baumfield et al, 2023).…”

Two Approaches to School Counseling as a Profession: From Boundaries to Core

“…The Australian Council of Professions provided an agreed definition of professions, in which expert knowledge is combined with trustworthiness (Baumfield et al, 2023). The legitimacy of who can perform the work and what is needed to perform and evaluate it (Freidson, 2001) may be strengthened based on two central sources: the profession's knowledge that adapts to new niches following changes in the workplace (Abbott, 1995), and having the trustworthiness of the public-partners in its character.…”