To study light-triggered self-healing in supramolecular materials, we synthesized supramolecular thermoplastic elastomers with mechanical properties that were reversibly modulated with temperature. By changing the supramolecular architecture, we created polymers with different temperature responses. Detailed characterization of the hydrogen-bonding material revealed dramatically different temperature and mechanical stress response due to two different stable states with changes in the hydrogen bonding interactions. A semicrystalline state showed no response to oscillatory shear deformations while the melt state behaved as a typical energy dissipative material with a clear crossover between storage and loss moduli. Comparison studies on heat generation after light excitation revealed no differences in photo-thermal conversion when an Fe(II)-phenanthroline chromophore was either physically blended into the H-bonding polymer or covalently attached to the supramolecular network. These materials showed healing of scratches with light-irradiation, as long as the overlap of material absorbance and laser excitation was sufficient. Differences in the efficiency and rate of photohealing were observed, depending on the type of supramolecular interaction, and these were attributed to the differences in the thermal response of the materials' moduli. Such results provide insight into how materials can be designed with chromophores and supramolecular bonding interactions to tune the lighthealing efficiency of the materials.