Changing higher education policies: From the deinstitutionalization to the reinstitutionalization of the research mission in Polish universities

Abstract

This paper analyzes changing higher education policies in Poland in the last two decades. It argues that top Polish public universities became divided, with different individual academic and institutional trajectories in the academic fields in which educational expansion occurred (social sciences) and in fields in which it was much less pronounced (natural sciences). Using the concepts drawn from new institutionalism in organizational studies, this paper views the 1990s as the period of the deinstitutionalization of traditional academic rules and norms in public universities, with growing uncertainty about the core of the academic identity. In the expansion era (1990-2005), prestigious public research universities became excessively teaching-oriented. In the period of educational contraction, their currently teaching-oriented segments are expected to become research-intensive. New legislation grounded in an instrumental view of higher education is interpreted as a return to a traditional academic normative consensus, with increased emphasis on, and funding for, the research mission.

The unfading power of collegiality? University governance in Poland in a European comparative and quantitative perspective

“…After the collapse of communism in 1989, universities became fully autonomous institutions and decision-making power returned to "high-ranking academics who governed by means of academic senates" (Dobbins, 2015, p. 24). The Polish government until the mid-2000s was weak in pursuing its policy goals, being primarily interested in ever-rising enrolments and trying to limit the negative influence of multiple employment among academics (Pinheiro and Antonowicz, 2014;Kwiek, 2003;Kwiek, 2012). A World Bank report (World Bank/EIB, 2004, pp.…”

The Changing Paths in Academic Careers in European Universities: Minor Steps and Major Milestones

“…Traditional academic values, closely associated with the public service responsibilities of universities and science, Scott argues, "have to come to terms with a new moral context in which the superiority of the public over the private can no longer be taken for granted" (Scott 2003, p. 299). 3 This new "moral context" has been widely supported by emergent EU social policies, especially social policies advocated in CEE countries, experimenting widely with various forms of privatization of social services (Kwiek 2012a(Kwiek , 2013. European institutions need to continue its reliance on traditional academic values (especially academic freedom and institutional autonomy) to be attractive.…”

European Universities and Educational and Occupational Intergenerational Social Mobility

“…While the expansion period substantially increased equitable access to higher education in Poland, upward social mobility viewed from a long-term perspective of change across generations is still limited. Consequently, from a European comparative perspective, there is much greater need for further fair and increased access to higher education than commonly assumed in educational research (for a Polish higher education massifi cation context from which the above data are derived, see Kwiek ( 2012aKwiek ( , 2013b, and for a European context, see Kwiek ( 2009aKwiek ( , 2013a). …”