We have performed a photoemission study of Ti4O7 around its two transition temperatures so as to cover the metallic, high-temperature insulating (bipolaron-liquid), and low-temperature insulating (bipolaron-crystal) phases. While the spectra of the low-temperature insulating phase show a finite gap at the Fermi level, the spectra of the high-temperature insulating phase are gapless, which is interpreted as a soft Coulomb gap due to dynamical disorder. We suggest that the spectra of the high-temperature disordered phase of Fe3O4, which exhibits a charge order-disorder transition (Verwey transition), can be interpreted in terms of a Coulomb gap.PACS numbers: 71.30.+h, 72.80.Ga, Since Mott [1] proposed the idea of variable-range hopping and minimum metallic conductivity for disordered systems and Anderson [2] raised the concept of localization due to disorder, physical properties of disordered solids have been extensively studied. Influence of Coulomb interaction on the electronic density of states (DOS) near the Fermi level (E F ) of disordered systems is one of the most fundamental issues to be clarified. Efros and Shklovskii [3] proposed that in disordered insulators long-range Coulomb interaction opens a soft Coulomb gap (SCG), whose DOS is proportional to (E − E F ) 2 . So far, there have been tunneling spectroscopic confirmations of the SCG in some disordered systems such as doped semiconductors [4]. Davies and Franz [5] pointed out the possibility of an SCG opening in the photoemission spectra of Na x Ta y W 1−y O 3 [6], but the experiments did not have sufficient energy resolution to critically address this problem. Another important issue is how short-range order (SRO) affects DOS near E F , that is, how the electronic structure evolves when a charge ordering develops from disorder to SRO to long-range order.Ti 4 O 7 is a suitable system to study the above problems: It undergoes successive phase transitions with decreasing temperature from a metal to a charge-ordered insulator via an insulator with SRO [7]. It is a system with nominally 0.5 3d electron per Ti, allowing two possible valence states of Ti 3+ (3d 1 ) and Ti 4+ (3d 0 ), and attracted particular attention in 1970's as a system where bipolarons, or singlet pairs of two polarons, are formed in real space [7][8][9]. Above T MI = 154 K, the system is in the metallic (M) phase and the Ti valence is believed to be uniform 3.5+ as shown in Fig. 1 (a). That is, the electrical resistivity ρ(T ) is metallic with Pauliparamagnetic χ(T ). With decreasing temperature, singlet Ti 3+ -Ti 3+ pairs, namely bipolarons, are formed, resulting in the metal-to-insulator transition at T MI with a steep increase in ρ(T ) by three orders of magnitude. At the same time, χ(T ) almost vanishes, reflecting the formation of the singlet bipolarons. We refer to this phase as the high-temperature insulating (HI) phase. Because the bipolarons are dynamically disordered in this phase as has been established by EPR studies [10], the HI phase may be called a bipolaron liquid. Sub...