To further our understanding of the role of Cl-and certain other monovalent anions in the oxygen evolving photosystem II of chloroplasts, dissociating and stabilizing anion effects on the extrinsic 17 and 23 kilodalton polypeptides of the photosynthetic water oxidizing complex were investigated. It was found that (a) the dissociation of the two polypeptides in Cl-free media of pH -7 was enhanced by millimolar concentrations of the divalent anion S042-and also by divalent cations like Mg2" and Ca2"; (b) the dissociation was opposed by relatively low concentrations of monovalent anions with an order of effectiveness Cl-= Br-> N03-> F > C104-; (c) at molar concentrations, S042-stabilized the binding of the 23 kilodalton polypeptide, while Cl-and Br-became dissociating agents, in agreement with studies by Blough and Sauer (1984 Biochim Biophys Acta 767: 377-381); (d) the binding of the polypeptides was strengthened at room temperature relative to 0°C, indicating an involvement of hydrophobic forces. It is suggested that a specific binding of Cl-, or certain substitutes, organizes the protein surfaces and/or the adjacent water layers in the water oxidizing complex in a way that not only stabilizes its assembly, but is essential for the catalytic mechanism as well. Binding of, or charge screening by, divalent ions interferes with this process. At high salt concentrations, all these effects are overridden by "lyotropic" actions of the solutes that affect the integrity of the water oxidizing protein complex by stabilizing or disrupting critical hydrophobic domains.Removal of Cl-from PSII of chloroplast thylakoids causes an aberration and interruption of the normal progress of charge accumulation in and perhaps around the Mn-cluster ofthe water oxidizing complex (for reviews, see Refs. 15, 17, and 21). However, the exact function of Cl-is not understood. Sandusky and Yocum (33) have proposed that an essential step in the mechanism of water oxidation is a ligation of Cl-to the Mn-cluster itself. This concept was developed on the basis of their finding that Cl-, in a competitive fashion, protected the water oxidizing mechanism from the inhibitory action of NH3 and various amines, the action of which was attributed to a binding to the oxidant storing Mn-complex. Taking an alternative view, Govindjee's group (8, 17) and we (19,21) have proposed various mechanistic versions for a role of protein-bound Cl-in the deprotonation events accompanying water oxidation. Such an indirect participation of the anion in the catalytic process was postulated because of precedents in other enzyme systems (8,14) and to account for the reported need of more than one Cl-per ' Supported by grant DMB 8304416 from the National Science Foundation.water oxidizing complex (35), the unique pH dependence of Clbinding (21), the complex pattern of 35Cl-NMR line broadening (2, 10), and the ability of other monovalent anions such as NO3 to serve as rather efficient substitutes for 18,24,28).The Cl-relations of PSII are known to be greatly influenc...