“…Upwelling of the old seawater in the subarctic North Pacific makes large ΔR in this region. As the circulation of surface and intermediate water in the NW Pacific changed between the last glacial maximum-last deglaciation and the Holocene (e.g., Ahagon et al, 2003 ;Ohkushi et al, 2003 ;Harada et al, 2004 ;Ikehara et al, 2006 ;Shibahara et al, 2007 ;Sagawa and Ikehara, 2008), the extent of the local reservoir effect in this area remains controversial. The local reservoir effect in the modern and former oceans has been estimated using radiocarbon dates from marine materials of known age, and radiocarbon dates from contemporaneous terrestrial and marine materials (e.g., Yoneda et al, 2001 ;Nakamura et al, 2007).…”