Challenges of a successful first‐year principal in Mexico

Abstract

PurposeThis case study is an attempt to understand the experience of a school principal, Arnulfo. The research question is: what are the challenges of one first‐year school director in Baja California, Mexico?Design/methodology/approachArnulfo participated in an interview and five focus groups at the Ensenada State Normal School. He kept a journal of incidents completed during April‐July 2006. A team of three researchers helped to write the case study. One researcher collected the data and wrote a summary in Spanish. A second researcher organized the material and translated it into English. The third researcher criticized and reviewed the write‐up.FindingsArnulfo faced a variety of challenges, but the burden of paperwork was the most serious. It can be understood on a number of levels. Bolman and Deal's four frames to understand organizations and leadership help to explain the complexity in terms of structural, human resource, symbolic, and political. The political frame was Arnulfo's greatest strength. He advocated for the school, formed alliances with parents, and took action to get the support of others.Practical implicationsThe analysis, if confirmed by broader studies with larger samples, would lead to several recommendations for educational administration preparation. Principals need to know about the structural tasks of paperwork; maintain relationships with supervisors to assure adequate support; understand the symbolic culture in which they work, and become savvy in the ways of politics.Originality/valueThe International Study of Principal Preparation will compare findings and offer perspective on the extent to which these issues are representative of challenges that directors face in eight other countries.

Early School Leadership Challenges in Kazakhstani Educational Management

“…The study findings by Slater, Garcia and Gorosave (2008) in Mexico replicated the findings of the researchers in English speaking countries with regard to paperwork because of bureaucracy, cultural, political and human conflicts.…”

Towards a conceptualization of the early career stage of principalship: current research, idiosyncrasies and future directions

“…For example, it was not long before the US and British NPs in Daresh and Male's (2000) study became aware of issues that remained hidden from them as they were not perceived by other players in the system as being in charge while acting on behalf of the principal. In the case of Arnulfo, a Mexican NP, though, paperwork continued to be a problem during certain periods of the year as supervisors wanted forms to be completed immediately (Slater et al 2008).…”

Tensions in leadership development: head teachers' experience in North Cyprus

“…The importance of school leadership for school improvement has been widely acknowledged internationally and the study of school leadership and school leaders has become a global trend (Oplatka 2004;Slater, Garcia, and Gorosave 2008). Particularly in the last two decades, the suitability of heroic leadership for sustainable school improvement has been called into question within this literature (Gronn 2003;Sugrue 2009) and theories of distributed leadership have become visible (Gronn 2000;Harris et al 2007;Leithwood, Mascall, and Strauss 2009;Spillane 2006).…”