Challenges and needed reforms in midwifery and nursing regulatory systems in India: Implications for education and practice

Abstract

Background In India, nursing regulation is generally weak, midwifery coexists with nursing, and 88% of nursing and midwifery education is provided by the private health sector. The Indian health system faces major challenges for health care provision due to poor quality, indeterminate regulatory functions and lack of reforms. Methods We undertook a qualitative investigation to understand midwifery and nursing education, and regulatory systems in India, through a review of the regulatory Acts, and an investigation of the perceptions and experiences of senior midwifery and nursing leaders representing administration, advocacy, education, regulation, research and service provision in India with an international perspective. Results There is a lack of importance accorded to midwifery roles within the nursing system. The councils and Acts do not adequately reflect midwifery practice, and remain a barrier to good quality care provision. The lack of required amendment of Acts, lack of representation of midwives and nurses in key governance positions in councils and committees have restrained and undermined leadership positions, which have also impaired the growth of the professions. A lack of opportunities for professional practice and unfair assessment practices are critical concerns affecting the quality of nursing and midwifery education in private institutions across India. Midwifery and nursing students are generally more vulnerable to discrimination and have less opportunities compared to medical students exacerbated by the gender-based challenges. Conclusions India is on the verge of a major regulatory reform with the National Nursing and Midwifery Commission Bill, 2020 being drafted, which makes this study a crucial and timely contribution. Our findings present the challenges that need to be addressed with regulatory reforms to enable opportunities for direct-entry into the midwifery profession, improving nursing education and practice by empowering midwives and nurses with decision-making powers for nursing and midwifery workforce governance.

Advancing quality and safety of perinatal services in India: opportunities for effective midwifery integration

“…The Council has limitations in human resources and infrastructure and lacks the authority needed to address key issues that directly impact nurses and midwives ( Sharma et al. , 2010 ; Mayra et al. , 2021b ).…”

“…, 2021b ). A recent study reported on the challenges of regulating midwifery scope of education and practice across five Indian states ( Figure 3 ), including a theory and practice mismatch in pre-service education; lack of teachers; medical domination in regulation and governance; lack of infrastructure; lack of leadership; corruption; a complete absence of regulation for private education systems and a lack of practice regulation ( Mayra et al. , 2021b ).…”

Contextual factors influencing the implementation of a new midwife education programme in India: a qualitative study

“…Moreover, the management of complaints and disciplinary procedures are also included, as are setting codes of conduct and ethical standards. Hence, the regulatory systems in India, when endorsed, will have implications for education and practice [ 30 ]. This challenging contextual factor has also been identified in other countries in the South-East Asia region (3).…”

Design, operation and strengthening of health practitioner regulation systems: A rapid integrative review

“…The largest group of studies was associated with regulatory strengthening programs in sub-Saharan African countries (62,131,182,187,190,201,202). There were also studies from Cambodia, India, Nepal and Vietnam (64,203,204). Initiatives to introduce or strengthen accreditation of education programs and institutions were embedded within broader HPR reform programs designed to improve the quality of the health workforce (62,64,201,205).…”