We report the case of a 72-year-old woman who experienced transient complete visual loss and a partial third nerve palsy in 1 eye following cataract surgery under local anesthesia in the fellow eye. Symptoms and signs were determined to result from the administration of a peribulbar block, which was presumably associated with ipsilateral transoptic nerve sheath spread. We believe this is the first report of contralateral amaurosis and oculomotor nerve palsy following peribulbar anesthesia.