Central gender theoretical concepts in health research: the state of the art

Abstract

Despite increasing awareness of the importance of gender perspectives in health science, there is conceptual confusion regarding the meaning and the use of central gender theoretical concepts. We argue that it is essential to clarify how central concepts are used within gender theory and how to apply them to health research. We identify six gender theoretical concepts as central and interlinked-but problematic and ambiguous in health science: sex, gender, intersectionality, embodiment, gender equity and gender equality. Our recommendations are that: the concepts sex and gender can benefit from a gender relational theoretical approach (i.e., a focus on social processes and structures) but with additional attention to the interrelations between sex and gender; intersectionality should go beyond additive analyses to study complex intersections between the major factors which potentially influence health and ensure that gendered power relations and social context are included; we need to be aware of the various meanings given to embodiment, which achieve an integration of gender and health and attend to different levels of analyses to varying degrees; and appreciate that gender equality concerns absence of discrimination between women and men while gender equity focuses on women's and men's health needs, whether similar or different. We conclude that there is a constant need to justify and clarify our use of these concepts in order to advance gender theoretical development. Our analysis is an invitation for dialogue but also a call to make more effective use of the knowledge base which has already developed among gender theorists in health sciences in the manner proposed in this paper.

Gender equality and smoking: a theory-driven approach to smoking gender differences in Spain

“…The theory of diffusion of innovations describes the time lapse between early adopters (highly educated men) and late adopters (highly educated women and less educated men, followed by less educated women), but fails to explain why women are consistently late adopters. Several gender theory concepts apply to the study of the tobacco epidemic and may help inform a theory-driven approach to smoking differences 5. Recently, female empowerment has been shown to be correlated with an increased prevalence of smoking among women relative to men6 and may be one of the factors that—together with industry activity7—shape the population distribution of smoking.…”

Show what you know and deal with stress yourself: a qualitative interview study of medical interns’ perceptions of stress and gender

“…The concept of ‘gender’ is commonly used to refer to the social aspects of being a man or a woman, differentiated from their biological aspects, for which the concept of ‘sex’ is used [36]. Gender is used to organize societies and is incorporated within institutions and individuals in many ways.…”

Gender Inequality in Mental Health: A Review from the South Asian Context

“…Whilst gender equity refers to the fairness and justice in the allocation of benefits and responsibilities between women and men, gender-based inequity may emanate from a psychosocial, epidemiological; or perhaps a global perspective. Extended understanding of gender and health, shaped by political, economic and cultural affairs 3,4,5 , shines light on the notion of gender inequality.…”