“…More recently, pollens were transformed using different nanoparticle carriers, such as rosette nanotubes (RNTs) in wheat (Cho et al, 2020), sheet-like clay nanoparticles in tomato (Yong et al, 2021), single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) in oil palm (Lew et al, 2020b), cationic cellpenetrating peptides (CPP) in wheat (Bilichak, Luu and Eudes, 2015) and triticale (Chugh, Amundsen and Eudes, 2009;Pepper et al, 2017), and iron oxide magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) in cotton (Zhao et al, 2017) and maize . However, like many other pollen transformation methods, some of these methods remain controversial due to the inability to reproduce results or obtain similar results in a different plant system or by a different research group.…”