Cell-composition effects in the analysis of DNA methylation array data: a mathematical perspective

Abstract

BackgroundThe impact of cell-composition effects in analysis of DNA methylation data is now widely appreciated. With the availability of a reference data set consisting of DNA methylation measurements on isolated cell types, it is possible to impute cell proportions and adjust for them, but there is increasing interest in methods that adjust for cell composition effects when reference sets are incomplete or unavailable.ResultsIn this article we present a theoretical basis for one such method, showing that the total effect of a phenotype on DNA methylation can be decomposed into orthogonal components, one representing the effect of phenotype on proportions of major cell types, the other representing either subtle effects in composition or global effects at focused loci, and that it is possible to separate these two types of effects in a finite data set. We demonstrate this principle empirically on nine DNA methylation data sets, showing that the first few principal components generally contain a majority of the information on cell-type present in the data, but that later principal components nevertheless contain information about a small number of loci that may represent more focused associations. We also present a new method for determining the number of linear terms to interpret as cell-mixture effects and demonstrate robustness to the choice of this parameter.ConclusionsTaken together, our work demonstrates that reference-free algorithms for cell-mixture adjustment can produce biologically valid results, separating cell-mediated epigenetic effects (i.e. apparent effects arising from differences in cell composition) from those that are not cell mediated, and that in general the interpretation of associations evident from DNA methylation should be carefully considered.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-015-0527-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Placental and Cord Blood Methylation of Genes Involved in Energy Homeostasis: Association With Fetal Growth and Neonatal Body Composition

“…of adjustment for cell composition in placenta/cord blood (24), the influence of maternal genetics on placental gene expression, the potential underrepresentation of differential methylation in CpG islands (25), and the inability to obtain-for ethical reasons-target tissues for the assessment of tissue-specific DNA methylation/expression. The strengths include the strict inclusion criteria (leading to distinct AGA and SGA populations and avoiding perinatal confounders) and the parallel assessments of placenta/cord blood pairs.…”

Positional effects revealed in Illumina Methylation Array and the impact on analysis

“…After filtering, 167,384 probes remained for downstream analysis. The package RefFreeEWAS was utilized to estimate cell proportion 53 , and function lm was used to correct for the cellular heterogeneity.…”

Computational genomics tools for dissecting tumour–immune cell interactions

“…The epigenome can be highly variable across different cell types as evident from epigenomewide association studies 42 . These cell-type-specific effects can be useful for the quantification of TILs and has been already harnessed by recent approaches 43 . Although the current availability of the reference methy lation patterns from purified cell types is still limi ted, these methods hold promise for determining TIL composition from bulk tumour tissue.…”