Causal inference as an emerging statistical approach in neurology: an example for epilepsy in the elderly

Abstract

The elderly population faces an increasing number of cases of chronic neurological conditions, such as epilepsy and Alzheimer’s disease. Because the elderly with epilepsy are commonly excluded from randomized controlled clinical trials, there are few rigorous studies to guide clinical practice. When the elderly are eligible for trials, they either rarely participate or frequently have poor adherence to therapy, thus limiting both generalizability and validity. In contrast, large observational data sets are increasingly available, but are susceptible to bias when using common analytic approaches. Recent developments in causal inference-analytic approaches also introduce the possibility of emulating randomized controlled trials to yield valid estimates. We provide a practical example of the application of the principles of causal inference to a large observational data set of patients with epilepsy. This review also provides a framework for comparative-effectiveness research in chronic neurological conditions.

Target trial emulation with multi-state model analysis to assess treatment effectiveness using clinical COVID-19 data

“…The emulated target trial’s protocol must include all key elements described by Hernan et al [ 21 ]. A grace period should be discussed with clinicians and determined by clinical relevance [ 23 ]. For COVID-19 patients, this period should be short enough to avoid heterogeneity between treatment arms.…”

“…Patients given treatment after the grace period were classified in the non-X-treated arm. The length of the grace period should be carefully defined and aligned with clinical practice [ 9 , 23 ]. In this educational example, this was defined for demonstration purposes.…”

Target Trial Emulation Using Hospital-Based Observational Data: Demonstration and Application in COVID-19

“…A grace period designated when treatment could be initiated after baseline. Implementing a grace period makes the treatment strategies used in clinical practice more pragmatic [ 17 , 34 ]. The length of the grace period should rely on a clinical decision and serve to reduce heterogeneity between patients [ 35 ].…”

Optimizing Helping Babies Breathe implementation in a resource limited setting to improve perinatal outcome

“…The sample sizes were large, between 9000 (pre/post cohort) in study I, to about 31000 newborns in study III, and the big cohorts are among the strengths of the three studies. The baseline group, without CQI including FBOS HBB simulation training, was compared to the group with CQI in a "similar" cohort (participants) and environment (HLH) [221][222][223]. Further, the focus of the studies was about learning and changes in clinical practice, and we believe that the findings can be generalized since learning processes are almost the same across different individuals and settings [98].…”