Caught Between Structure and Agency: The Gender of Violence and Prostitution in Papua New Guinea

Abstract

Luise White's (1991) framework for studying prostitution empirically, in terms of its "labor forms," uncovers the structure and function of "sex industries." In this essay I describe and analyze four such labor forms based upon fieldwork conducted during 1990‐92 on Dam island, capital of Papua New Guinea's Western Province. Those forms are: 1) family, 2) freelance, 3) sex broker, and 4) outdoor bush. Amidst these different forms of sexual networking, including marriage, women are caught between their opportunities to act agentially and the structures of domination that impinge upon them — patriarchy, capital, heterosexuality, and the state. Using what Allen Feldman calls "zones of terror" to develop an ethnography of violence, and to sharpen our sense of anthropological praxis, 1 clarify the difference between gender violence and gendered violence. Gender violence consists of social, economic, political, and cultural double standards that are multiplying in form and intensity through Papua New Guinea. Gendered violence, or sexually embodied violence wrought through genitalia, is likewise multiplying and becoming eroticized. I conclude that anthropological praxis requires not only doing "good enough" ethnography but situating violence in an expanded, reflexive field that includes ethnographers.

The Architecture of Feminicide: The State, Inequalities, and Everyday Gender Violence in Honduras

“…Hammar (1999) observes that differences in a genderimbalanced political economy that disadvantage women represent gender violence, whereas acts of violence, including physical, psychological and linguistic, constitute gendered violence (1999,91). And it is precisely the expression of gender violence and gendered violence in everyday life (in the home and the streets) that contributes to their normalization-they are always there, part of the way things are.…”

Subverting Justice: Socio-Legal Determinants of Impunity for Violence against Women in Guatemala

“…Gender violence refers to gender imbalances in the broader structures that disadvantage women; gendered violence comprises the various acts of violence perpetrated against women, consciously or unconsciously, as a mechanism of control, which is often perceived as a normal way of keeping women "in line" [21]. These acts, including physical, psychological and linguistic violence, are committed in a context of gender inequality and serve to sustain this inequality through force and explicit or implicit threats.…”

Great Ancestral Women: Sexuality, Gendered Mobility, and HIV among the Bamu and Gogodala of Papua New Guinea

“…This third kind of sex was defined as sex in a public place in exchange for money, goods, or services. It included sexual services that the Bamu provided in the early 1990s in Daru and in other areas of the Western Province (Hammar , , ). Only married women, widows or divorced women could participate in mahi gabo and then only if they had been introduced to it by other women.…”

“…Many Kamula men believe, then, that in order to avoid contracting HIV, one should avoid having sex with Bamu women or sex workers more generally (see Hammar :53). Hammar (:81) notes that Bamu people in Daru were actually blamed for creating certain forms of prostitution (like sagapari ) in addition to being stigmatized more generally for the murder of the Kiwai version of Sido, sorcery, sexual promiscuity, bellicosity, and resistance to Christianity.…”