The mechanism of -6 polyunsaturated fatty acid oxidation by wild-type cyclooxygenase 2 and the Y334F variant, lacking a conserved hydrogen bond to the catalytic tyrosyl radical/tyrosine, was examined for the first time under physiologically relevant conditions. The enzymes show apparent bimolecular rate constants and deuterium kinetic isotope effects that increase in proportion to co-substrate concentrations before converging to limiting values. The trends exclude multiple dioxygenase mechanisms as well as the proposal that initial hydrogen atom abstraction from the fatty acid is the first irreversible step in catalysis. Temperature dependent kinetic studies reinforce the novel finding that hydrogen transfer from the reduced catalytic tyrosine to a terminal peroxyl radical is the first irreversible step that controls regio-and stereospecific product formation.Cyclooxygenases 1 and 2 (COX-1 and COX-2) 2 are tyrosyl radical-utilizing hemoproteins with dioxygenase and peroxidase activities (1-3). Also known as prostaglandin H synthases, these structurally homologous enzymes are expressed by distinct genes, resulting in differences in cellular localization and regulation. COX-1 and COX-2 use O 2 to oxidize arachidonic acid (AA) as well as linoleic acid (LA), its dietary precursor, by Equations 1 and 2. COX-1 has a smaller active site, resulting in greater specificity for AA over LA than seen in the larger, more promiscuous COX-2 (4).Each dioxygenase reaction starts with initial hydrogen abstraction (from AA or LA) by a catalytic tyrosyl radical. Antarafacial O 2 trapping (of AA ⅐ or LA ⅐ ) leads to a peroxyl radical that reoxidizes the catalytic tyrosine in a second hydrogen transfer step, thus propagating catalysis. The prostaglandin G 2 (PGG 2 ) and acyclic hydroperoxide compounds (HPETEs and HPODEs) formed are processed by the enzyme's peroxidase activity, which consumes two reducing equivalents to generate prostaglandin H 2 (PGH 2 ) and acyclic hydroxylated compounds (hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acids (HETEs) and hydroxyoctadecadienoic acids (HODEs)) together with H 2 O. In vitro studies commonly use phenol as the reductant. Earlier work demonstrated simple, saturating behavior when phenol reacts with COX-2 (5) but not COX-1 where acceleration and inhibition of dioxygenase catalysis are observed upon raising the phenol concentration (6).AA and LA bind to COX-2 in similar L-shaped conformations (Fig. 1). The reactive bisallylic C-H bond is thereby positioned close to the catalytic tyrosyl radical (Tyr-371 ⅐ ) (7, 8). Tyr-371 ⅐ forms rapidly upon exposure of the enzyme containing Fe(III)(protoporphyrin IX (Por)) to hydroperoxide compounds present at trace levels in AA and LA preparations (9). A Fe(IV)ϭO(Por ϩ ⅐ ) intermediate, typical in heme peroxidases, has been implicated as the oxidant (10). This species resides approximately 5 Å away from Tyr-371, which hydrogen bonds to 12). By analogy, Mn(III)(Por)-reconstituted COX-2 likely reacts with hydroperoxide compounds via a Mn(V)ϭO(Por) intermediate to produce Tyr-371 ...