Case Report: Lung Disease in World Trade Center Responders Exposed to Dust and Smoke: Carbon Nanotubes Found in the Lungs of World Trade Center Patients and Dust Samples

Abstract

ContextAfter the collapse of the World Trade Center (WTC) on 11 September 2001, a dense cloud of dust containing high levels of airborne pollutants covered Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn, New York. Between 60,000 and 70,000 responders were exposed. Many reported adverse health effects.Case presentationIn this report we describe clinical, pathologic, and mineralogic findings in seven previously healthy responders who were exposed to WTC dust on either 11 September or 12 September 2001, who developed severe respiratory impairment or unexplained radiologic findings and underwent video-assisted thoracoscopic surgical lung biopsy procedures at Mount Sinai Medical Center. WTC dust samples were also examined. We found that three of the seven responders had severe or moderate restrictive disease clinically. Histopathology showed interstitial lung disease consistent with small airways disease, bronchiolocentric parenchymal disease, and nonnecrotizing granulomatous condition. Tissue mineralogic analyses showed variable amounts of sheets of aluminum and magnesium silicates, chrysotile asbestos, calcium phosphate, and calcium sulfate. Small shards of glass containing mostly silica and magnesium were also found. Carbon nanotubes (CNT) of various sizes and lengths were noted. CNT were also identified in four of seven WTC dust samples.DiscussionThese findings confirm the previously reported association between WTC dust exposure and bronchiolar and interstitial lung disease. Long-term monitoring of responders will be needed to elucidate the full extent of this problem. The finding of CNT in both WTC dust and lung tissues is unexpected and requires further study.

Asbestos in commercial cosmetic talcum powder as a cause of mesothelioma in women

“…29 One air sample and two blanks were also analyzed by NIOSH Method 7402 via TEM to determine the percentage of asbestos fibers among the fibers counted by PCM. 30 An air sample collected from within was tested as described above by EPA AHERA method. 24 …”

Carbon nanotubes and pleural damage: Perspectives of nanosafety in the light of asbestos experience

“…30 Data published by Murr and co-workers 31,32 identified MWCNTs and carbonaceous nanoparticles in methane or propane flames generated by kitchen stoves and from fuel-gas combustions. Notably, Wu et al 33 reported that CNTs have been found in lung tissues from subjects exposed to dusts and smoke during the 11 September 2001 collapse of the World Trade Center in New York. Muller and Nowack 34 calculated the predicted environmental concentration for CNTs in the air and they estimated a value between 0.0015 g / m 3 ͑defined as "realistic exposure"͒ and 0.0023 g / m 3 ͑high exposure͒.…”

Destruction of the World Trade Center Towers. Lessons Learned from an Environmental Health Disaster

“…Findings of persistent large particles in sputum, bronchoalveolar lavage, and lung biopsies suggest overload of normal defense mechanisms (32)(33)(34)(35).…”