Care Escalation: Teaching Residents How to Effectively Communicate Patient Care Concerns

Abstract

Introduction: Care escalation for patients at risk of deterioration requires that care team members are able to effectively communicate patient care concerns to more senior team members. However, multiple factors inhibit residents from escalating their concerns, which contributes to treatment delays and sentinel events. Methods: We developed and implemented an annual 1-and 2-hour escalation curriculum for senior pediatric residents from the University of Colorado. The curriculum consisted of case presentations (one for the 1-hour or two for the 2-hour session), lecture, large-group discussion, and small-group activities. Faculty and fellows facilitated small groups, in which barriers to care escalation and specific tools for effective escalation were discussed. We administered precurriculum surveys for resident self-reflection and postcurriculum surveys for curriculum evaluation. Results: The curriculum was delivered to 179 residents over 3 years (2016-2018). Surveys were administered during the first 2 years, and 87% of participants completed pre-and postcurriculum surveys. Of all respondents, 88% believed that the curriculum helped them recognize care escalation barriers, and 85% believed that they learned skills for effective escalation. Resident comfort in asking for attending physician help improved from 52% to 95% (p < .001). Analysis of postsurvey open-ended responses indicated that residents valued listening to faculty share their personal experiences of escalating care. Discussion: The development and implementation of a curriculum to improve resident comfort and perceived ability to escalate patient care concerns are feasible and effective. Further work is needed to evaluate the impact of this curriculum in the clinical setting.

Appealing to Tacit Knowledge and Axiology to Enhance Medical Practice in the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review and Hermeneutic Bioethical Analysis

“…In AA the discussions touched on matters related mainly to decision making regarding end-of-life ( 35 ), the development of communication skills with patient-parents to take shared decisions ( 36 ), and the search for ethical assistance by the medical team ( 37 ). Reflection and discussion as a means of confronting ethical challenges ( 38 , 39 ) are also mentioned, as well as aspects related to ethics education ( 40 ), professional autonomy ( 41 ), and conflict of interest when writing clinical practice guidelines ( 42 ).…”

HeartWatch: Implementing a Pediatric Heart Center Program to Prevent Cardiac Arrests Outside the ICU

“…Several studies have described challenges associated with the escalation of care, including interpersonal factors (e.g., existing hierarchies), difficulty recognizing deteriorating patients, and expectations of specific outcomes (e.g., only calling when the patient truly needs ICU care). [20][21][22][23] A system like HeartWatch may decrease barriers to escalation because it prompts those with concerns to have a team discussion. This is especially important in an academic medical center, where turnover in an ACCU can be high due to medical trainee scheduled rotations and general staff (e.g., nursing) turnover.…”

A care escalation framework to address lapses in donning and doffing of personal protective equipment during the COVID-19 pandemic

“…Escalation of care involves prompt recognition of deterioration in a patient's clinical status, and timely communication of concerns to the care team. 1 , 2 In some circumstances, this may require junior trainees to speak to up to those more senior. Communication failure has been recognized to cause sentinel events and delayed escalation can lead to safety issues resulting in significant morbidity and mortality for patients.…”

“… 2 Interpersonal factors include traditional hierarchical structures, fear of appearing incompetent, and desire for autonomy by junior members of the team. 1 , 2 , 4 Communication across hierarchies can be challenging. Resident physicians may be reluctant to alert attending physicians to safety concerns, as the attending physician may be in a position to have a direct influence on the resident's future career.…”

“…They include fostering a safe environment to promote communication across hierarchies by making expectations clear, setting expectations early, standardization of communication, and practice of these skills in a safe environment, such as in simulation. 1 , 2 , 4 Improving patient safety, including adherence to IPAC measures, requires a culture of mutual respect, accountability, and commitment to improvement. This must be reflected in the learning environment, and role modeled by those more senior.…”