Capturing multi-stage fuzzy uncertainties in hybrid system dynamics and agent-based models for enhancing policy implementation in health systems research

Abstract

BackgroundIn practical research, it was found that most people made health-related decisions not based on numerical data but on perceptions. Examples include the perceptions and their corresponding linguistic values of health risks such as, smoking, syringe sharing, eating energy-dense food, drinking sugar-sweetened beverages etc. For the sake of understanding the mechanisms that affect the implementations of health-related interventions, we employ fuzzy variables to quantify linguistic variable in healthcare modeling where we employ an integrated system dynamics and agent-based model.MethodologyIn a nonlinear causal-driven simulation environment driven by feedback loops, we mathematically demonstrate how interventions at an aggregate level affect the dynamics of linguistic variables that are captured by fuzzy agents and how interactions among fuzzy agents, at the same time, affect the formation of different clusters(groups) that are targeted by specific interventions.ResultsIn this paper, we provide an innovative framework to capture multi-stage fuzzy uncertainties manifested among interacting heterogeneous agents (individuals) and intervention decisions that affect homogeneous agents (groups of individuals) in a hybrid model that combines an agent-based simulation model (ABM) and a system dynamics models (SDM). Having built the platform to incorporate high-dimension data in a hybrid ABM/SDM model, this paper demonstrates how one can obtain the state variable behaviors in the SDM and the corresponding values of linguistic variables in the ABM.ConclusionsThis research provides a way to incorporate high-dimension data in a hybrid ABM/SDM model. This research not only enriches the application of fuzzy set theory by capturing the dynamics of variables associated with interacting fuzzy agents that lead to aggregate behaviors but also informs implementation research by enabling the incorporation of linguistic variables at both individual and institutional levels, which makes unstructured linguistic data meaningful and quantifiable in a simulation environment. This research can help practitioners and decision makers to gain better understanding on the dynamics and complexities of precision intervention in healthcare. It can aid the improvement of the optimal allocation of resources for targeted group (s) and the achievement of maximum utility. As this technology becomes more mature, one can design policy flight simulators by which policy/intervention designers can test a variety of assumptions when they evaluate different alternatives interventions.

Modeling disease progression and treatment pathways for depression jointly using agent based modeling and system dynamics

“…The treatment pathways turned out to be complex and such complexity would not be easily added to the AB model. The design used in this study, where individuals are modeled using ABM and the health system is modeled using SD, has been implemented elsewhere ( 89 ). Such design may be referred as “process-environment” ( 68 ) which has been used in the studies related to healthcare ( 16 ).…”

Using a fuzzy cognitive map to assess interventions to reduce antimicrobial resistance in a Swedish One Health system context under potential climate change conditions

“…The process evaluates the AV of each component based on its relationships at each discrete time step (iteration), leading to three different behaviours, equilibrium, a cyclical state, or total chaotic behaviour (Harmati et al, 2021). FCM software enables exploration of the system dynamics, pattern recognition, and "what-if" scenarios for decision processes and policy assessment (Liu et al, 2018;Alipour et al, 2019;Harmati et al, 2021). Scenario analyses involved altering the AV of components, reflecting a certain scenario (an intervention), performing an inference process in FCM Expert (Mcculloch and Pitts, 1990), and calculating percentage change between the AVs for the indicator components (Table 1) at steady state (equilibrium) and the AV from the baseline scenario (inference process conducted with the initial AV of all components).…”

Assessing the Dynamic Outcomes of Containment Strategies against COVID-19 under Different Public Health Governance Structures: A Comparison between Pakistan and Bangladesh

“…SDMs have been widely applied in investigating contagious diseases [ 17 , 18 ] and non-communicable chronic diseases [ 19 , 20 ]. The applications of SDMs have been widely seen in the areas of health service improvement [ 21 , 22 ], impact assessments of policies and interventions [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 ], resource allocation [ 25 ], national health planning [ 27 , 28 ], and the determining the complexities of health-related socioeconomic systems [ 29 , 30 ]. SDMs have also found their extensive applications in the research of the COVID-19 pandemic including (but not limited to) spreading dynamics, trend analysis and prediction, impact assessments of control and containment measures, etc.…”