Cancer survivors' experiences with breakdowns in patient‐centered communication

Abstract

Objective: This study analyzed cancer survivors' communication experiences that fell short of being patient-centered. Patients' descriptions of communication "breakdowns" were analyzed according to domain (eg, information exchange, fostering relationships, and managing emotions), whether it was a breakdown of commission (what was communicated) or omission (what should have been communicated) and whether it involved a clinician or the health care organization. Methods: Cancer survivors (from an online panel of patients) completed the Patients Assessment of Communication Experience measure. Ratings less than "excellent" elicited a prompt asking where communication fell short. Communication breakdowns were categorized as one of commission/omission, if it involved a clinician/health care system, and within which communication domain. Thematic analysis explored how communication breakdowns affected respondents' cancer care experiences. Results: Overall communication was rated as less than excellent by 153 respondents, of which 79 identified a specific communication breakdown. Over half (n = 43, 54%) were problems of omission, mostly attributed to interaction with health care organizations (n = 25). Breakdowns of commission (n = 36, 46%) occurred primarily within clinical encounters (n = 32). Most breakdowns were problems of information exchange (49%) or fostering relationships (27%). Three overarching themes emergedemotional fallout from unmet information needs, inattention to patient perspective, and uncertainty about navigation and team communication. Conclusions: Patient-centered communication breakdowns create distress that worsens patients' cancer care experiences. Communication skills training for clinicians should address listening, perspective taking, and assessing/satisfying patients' information and emotional needs. Health care organizations should enhance processes to provide timely, useful information to patients. KEYWORDS cancer, communication breakdowns, information exchange, oncology, patient-centered communication, physician-patient relationships 1 | BACKGROUND Effective communication among health care providers, patients, and families is critical for achieving patient-centered medical care. 1Productive interactions are not only important for achieving quality cancer care delivery, but they also contribute to improved outcomes for cancer patients. 2,3 Unfortunately, patient-centered communication in cancer care is often lacking. Surveys report that a sizeable

Needs, preferences, and experiences of adult cancer survivors in accessing dietary information post‐treatment: A scoping review

“…A greater understanding of the needs, preferences, and experiences of cancer survivors in accessing dietary information post‐treatment can support healthcare professionals to actively engage cancer survivors towards evidence‐based dietary information and support, as per survivorship care guidelines. Further, clinicians’ understanding of, and attention to, cancer survivors’ information needs and preferences contributes to positive care experiences within healthcare settings (Street et al, 2019).…”

How Communication “Failed” or “Saved the Day”: Counterfactual Accounts of Medical Errors

“…For those recounting medical errors, health care providers were most often the party responsible for communication failures. Consistent with research across various health care settings ( 17 , 18 ), communication problems were about information exchange, which fell into 2 categories. First, there were errors of omission in which needed information was insufficient, inaccurate, or delayed.…”

“…First, health care providers need systems in place to ensure patients and families receive relevant information in a timely manner. Patients and families see inadequacies of information as avoidable and distressing communication breakdowns ( 17 ) that can contribute to medical errors and perhaps legal action ( 34 ). Because patients need information and support in difficult situations ( 35 ), health care providers can use simple communication strategies to mitigate problems associated with unmet information needs.…”

The clinical-care focused psychological interview (CLiC): a structured tool for the assessment of cancer patients’ needs

“…The relationship between healthcare provider and patients is an essential component of the treatment and is based on good communication [40]. Good communication and, consequently, a good relationship can have different positive outcomes: patient's satisfaction with care [40], better adherence to the treatment [41], support in emotion regulation [42]. Patient-physician communication can be a useful instrument in identifying patient's needs and it can bring to a better comprehension of medical information [43].…”