Can Targeted Intervention Mitigate Early Emotional and Behavioral Problems?: Generating Robust Evidence within Randomized Controlled Trials

Abstract

This study examined the impact of a targeted Irish early intervention program on children’s emotional and behavioral development using multiple methods to test the robustness of the results. Data on 164 Preparing for Life participants who were randomly assigned into an intervention group, involving home visits from pregnancy onwards, or a control group, was used to test the impact of the intervention on Child Behavior Checklist scores at 24-months. Using inverse probability weighting to account for differential attrition, permutation testing to address small sample size, and quantile regression to characterize the distributional impact of the intervention, we found that the few treatment effects were largely concentrated among boys most at risk of developing emotional and behavioral problems. The average treatment effect identified a 13% reduction in the likelihood of falling into the borderline clinical threshold for Total Problems. The interaction and subgroup analysis found that this main effect was driven by boys. The distributional analysis identified a 10-point reduction in the Externalizing Problems score for boys at the 90th percentile. No effects were observed for girls or for the continuous measures of Total, Internalizing, and Externalizing problems. These findings suggest that the impact of this prenatally commencing home visiting program may be limited to boys experiencing the most difficulties. Further adoption of the statistical methods applied here may help to improve the internal validity of randomized controlled trials and contribute to the field of evaluation science more generally.Trial Registration: ISRCTN Registry ISRCTN04631728

Impact of an early childhood intervention on the home environment, and subsequent effects on child cognitive and emotional development: A secondary analysis

“…The intervention included a home visiting program, a baby massage course, and the Triple P Positive Parenting Program. The efficacy of PFL was demonstrated in previously published studies reporting on this randomized controlled trial by showing moderate-to-large effects on mother-reported behavioral problems [10,11], cognition [11,12], and health problems (asthma, chest infections, health visit) up to 4 years of age [11,13]. In addition, the final outcome report from this trial revealed positive treatment effects on emotional problems (e.g.…”

Sex differences in the development of physical aggression: An intergenerational perspective and implications for preventive interventions

“…Other encouraging results come from The Dublin Preparing for Life study, an intensive (5-year) preventive intervention started during pregnancy. Initial results have shown that significant impacts on behavior problems and health can be observed during early childhood development (Côté, Orri, Tremblay, & Doyle, 2018;Doyle, McGlanaghy, O'Farrelly, & Tremblay, 2016).…”

A Multicomponent Early Intervention Program and Trajectories of Behavior, Cognition, and Health

“…With this study, we used a randomized controlled trial (RCT) conducted in Ireland (the Preparing for Life [PFL] program) to investigate whether the impact of the multicomponent intervention varied according to trajectories of children's behavior (externalizing, internalizing), cognition (general cognitive skills, vocabulary), and health service use (health clinic visits). Previous PFL studies revealed positive effects for average treatment effects for behavioral problems scores, 23 health problems (asthma, chest infections), 24 nutrition, 25 and cognition. 26 With this study, we tested the differential impact of the intervention for subgroups of children defined by latent trajectories of skills.…”