Can’t Stop this Feeling: Tracing the Origins of Historical Empathy During the Cold War Era, 1950–1980

Abstract

Historical empathy is a critical aspect of history and social science education that has its roots in the inquiry-based education movements of the twentieth century. Although the term "historical empathy" is not specifically mentioned in most history curriculum documents in the United States, dozens of "new social studies" initiatives were created by scholars and practitioners that encompassed the goals of historical empathy. The fierce political rivalry between the United States and Soviet Union post-Sputnik led to unparalleled education funding that included not only math and science, but also foreign languages and the history and social science disciplines. These New Social Studies initiatives fostered inquiry-based learning that asked students to consider what it meant to be human. In this research, we trace the contemporary origins of historical empathy through a review of education documents and curricular materials from 1950 through 1980. We examine how the work of educational organizations and leaders during the Cold War era impacted historical empathy as a curricular goal.

Stuck in a box: Elementary teacher education students’ perspectives of the impact of edTPA on social studies instruction

“…Challenges to promote social studies in elementary education did not originate with edTPA, nor with testing mandates as outlined by NCLB. When A Nation at Risk was published in 1983, concerns arose with the United States falling behind competitor nations, hence leading to the prevalence of mandated standardized testing in math and ELA to measure student achievement and enforce accountability measures on schools from the state and federal level (Perrotta & Bohan, 2020). Not surprisingly, elementary teachers who work in states where social studies is a tested subject tend to teach that subject more as compared to teachers whose states do not mandate standardized exams for social studies (Heafner, 2018; Hawkman et al, 2015; Fitchett et al, 2014a; Fitchett & Heafner, 2010).…”

A study of elementary teacher’s perspectives on professional development for social studies

“…When A Nation at Risk was published in 1983, concerns arose about the United States falling behind competitor nations (Perrotta and Bohan, 2013). The 2001 No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) further contributed to the marginalization of social studies education as federal and states' emphasis focused on standardized testing in math and English language arts (ELA) to measure student achievement and school accountability.…”