Can social capital help explain enrolment (or lack thereof) in community-based health insurance? Results of an exploratory mixed methods study from Senegal

Abstract

Original citation:Mladovsky, Philipa, Soors, Werner, Ndiaye, Pascal, Ndiaye, Alfred and Criel, Bart (2014) 2 Abstract CBHI has achieved low population coverage in West Africa and elsewhere. Studies seeking to explain this point to inequitable enrolment, adverse selection, lack of trust in scheme management and information and low quality of health care. Interventions to address these problems have been proposed yet enrolment rates remain low. This exploratory study proposes that an underresearched determinant of CBHI enrolment is social capital. Fieldwork comprising a household survey and qualitative interviews was conducted in Senegal in 2009. Levels of bonding and bridging social capital among 720 members and non-members of CBHI across three case study schemes are compared. The results of the logistic regression suggest that, controlling for age and gender, in all three case studies members were significantly more likely than non-members to be enrolled in another community association, to have borrowed money from sources other than friends and relatives and to report having control over all community decisions affecting daily life. In two case studies, having privileged social relationships was also positively correlated with enrolment. After controlling for additional socioeconomic and health variables, the results for borrowing money remained significant. Additionally, in two case studies, reporting having control over community decisions and believing that the community would cooperate in an emergency were significantly positively correlated with enrolment. The results suggest that CBHI members had greater bridging social capital which provided them with solidarity, risk pooling, financial protection and financial credit. Qualitative interviews with 109 individuals selected from the household survey confirm this interpretation. The results ostensibly suggest that CBHI schemes should build on bridging social capital to increase coverage, for example by enrolling households through community associations.However, this may be unadvisable from an equity perspective. It is concluded that since enrolment in CBHI was less common not only among the poor, but also among those with less social capital and less power, strategies should focus on removing social as well as financial barriers to obtaining financial protection from the cost of ill health.

An in-depth investigation of the causes of persistent low membership of community-based health insurance: a case study of the mutual health organisation of Dar Naïm, Mauritania

“…This framework was applied to CBHI schemes in Senegal where social capital was investigated as a determinant of membership [ 60 ]. Bridging social capital at local level was measured by membership of other community associations to which people belonged, and indeed, households enrolled in CBHI were significantly more likely to be members of other associations than non-member households.…”

Ghana’s National Health insurance scheme and maternal and child health: a mixed methods study

“…Such an approach enabled us to obtain a richer and more comprehensive understanding of individual behaviors and community and contextual dynamics related to insurance, than a single method alone [ 23 ]. Mixed-methods approaches are increasingly being used in the study of diverse models of health insurance across Africa, reflecting the need to integrate multiple perspectives and sources of information to understand the complex determinants of insurance uptake and the relationships between insurance and outcomes [ 21 , 24 , 25 ].…”

The measurement of bridging social capital in population health research

“…Mladovsky et al (2014) To compare levels of social capital among members and non-members of three CBHI schemes in Senegal.…”