Can network science reveal structure in a complex healthcare system? A network analysis using data from emergency surgical services

Abstract

IntroductionHospitals are complex systems and optimising their function is critical to the provision of high quality, cost effective healthcare. Metrics of performance have to date focused on the performance of individual elements rather than the whole system. Manipulation of individual elements of a complex system without an integrative understanding of its function is undesirable and may lead to counterintuitive outcomes and a holistic metric of hospital function might help design more efficient services.ObjectivesWe aimed to use network analysis to characterise the structure of the system of perioperative care for emergency surgical admissions in our tertiary care hospital.DesignWe constructed a weighted directional network representation of the emergency surgical services using patient location data from electronic health records.SettingA single-centre tertiary care hospital in the UK.ParticipantsWe selected data from the retrospective electronic health record data of all unplanned admissions with a surgical intervention during their stay during a 3.5-year period, which resulted in a set of 16 500 individual admissions.MethodsWe then constructed and analysed the structure of this network using established methods from network science such as degree distribution, betweenness centrality and small-world characteristics.ResultsThe analysis showed the service to be a complex system with scale-free, small-world network properties. We also identified such potential hubs and bottlenecks in the system.ConclusionsOur holistic, system-wide description of a hospital service may provide tools to inform service improvement initiatives and gives us insights into the architecture of a complex system of care. The implications for the structure and resilience of the service is that while being robust in general, the system may be vulnerable to outages at specific key nodes.

Machine Learning for Real-Time Aggregated Prediction of Hospital Admission for Emergency Patients

“…This work draws attention to some challenges that make technically high-performing systems perform poorly for their intended use, including model drift, and considers how to address them. Ultimately of course, crowding in EDs is an outcome of system-wide issues downstream such as bottlenecks and capacity constraints 7,39 . AI does not do anything on its own; to succeed, it must be connected to real-world processes 40 .…”

Multiple outcome interactions in healthcare systems: a participatory outcome mapping approach

“…For example, emergency pathways were used to construct emergency services networks by assigning patient locations as nodes and patient transfers as edges. Edges were weighted considering the type of pathways and the frequency of transfer (Kohler and Ercole 2020). Different network measures such as betweenness centrality were especially meaningful to identify outcomes that construct a bridge; however, these outcomes may have a significant impact on the integration and functioning of the system if they are unattended.…”

A holistic outcome-based approach to co-create healthcare systems.

“…Network analysis is the process by which to model systems using two essential elements such as nodes and links (Havlin et al, 2012). Studies have used network analysis in healthcare systems for different and new purposes (Benhiba et al, 2017), such as the analysis of pathways (Kohler & Ercole, 2020). These new studies have assigned to different system elements the role of nodes and links.…”