Can Environmental Tax Policy Really Help to Reduce Pollutant Emissions? An Empirical Study of a Panel ARDL Model Based on OECD Countries and China

Abstract

Under the background that environmental tax has increasingly become the main means of environmental governance in various countries, it is particularly important to study the effect of environmental tax on reducing pollutants and then put forward suggestions for building a scientific and rational environmental tax system. The novelty of this paper is the investigation of the pollutant emission reduction effects of environmental taxes in Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries and Chinese provinces at the same time, and further comparison of the pollutant emission reduction effects of environmental taxes in OECD and China under different environmental tax collection scales, industrial added value levels, and economic development conditions based on Auto-Regressive Distributed Lag Modelling Approach (ARDL). The data are derived from environmental taxes and pollutants of OECD countries from 1994 to 2016 and Chinese provinces from 2004 to 2016. The results show that from the overall regression results, environmental taxes really help to reduce pollutant emissions, both in OECD countries and China. From the grouping regression results, the OECD countries and Chinese inland provinces with small-scale or medium-level of environmental tax revenue and higher level of economic growth all show better emission reduction effects, while OECD countries with low industrial added value and Chinese inland provinces with high industrial added value have more significant effects on pollutant emission reduction via environmental taxes.

Reducing Air Pollution: Are Environmental Taxes Enough to Help the EU Member States Reach Climate Neutrality by 2050?

“…The other control variables are widely used in studies regarding the efficiency of environment taxes [12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20] and the expectation is that this research will confirm previous results. Therefore, the anticipated result is that the consumption of oil will have a significant positive effect on emissions of both carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases, in general.…”

“…Authors He, Ning, Yu, Xiong, Shen, and Jin use a panel auto-regressive distributed lag modelling approach to study the efficiency of environment taxes in 35 OECD countries and China. The authors find evidence that OECD countries with low industrial added value show "relatively good" short-term pollutant emission reduction effects for environmental taxes, but in China the provinces with high industrial added value are the ones with a better pollution reduction effect for the environmental taxes [20]. Other Chinese authors show that integrated policy mixes, in particular revenue from carbon taxes being used to reduce capital taxes or to provide a clean energy subsidy would improve the performance of carbon taxes in reducing carbon dioxide emissions [21].…”

Do environmental taxes and environmental stringency policies reduce CO2 emissions? Evidence from 7 emerging economies

“…Thus, the efforts of fossil fuelconsuming countries to reduce global warming can be undermined by fossil owners. However, the empirical evidence on the Green Paradox is not conclusive (see He et al 2019b; van der Werf and Di Maria 2012; Zhang et al 2017). It is for this and other similar reasons that pollution is not only one of the "greatest existential challenges" (Landrigan et al 2018) but also one of the "hardest to tackle for governments all over the world" (Van der Werf and Di Maria 2012).…”

Exploring the Role of Carbon Taxation Policies on CO2 Emissions: Contextual Evidence from Tax Implementation and Non-Implementation European Countries

“…In a comparative study, He et al [27] investigated the effectiveness of environmental taxes in reducing pollution levels in China and OECD countries. Based on the findings of Auto-Regressive Distributed Lag Modelling Approach (ARDL) for annual data of Chinese provinces and OECD countries, the research concluded that environmental related taxes are an effective tool to curb the pollution levels.…”