Can changes in spending on health and social care explain the recent mortality trends in Scotland? A protocol for an observational study

Abstract

IntroductionThere have been steady reductions in mortality rates in the majority of high-income countries, including Scotland, since 1945. However, reductions in mortality rates have slowed down since 2012–2014 in these nations; and have reversed in some cases. Deaths among those aged 55+ explain a large amount of these changing mortality trends in Scotland. Increased pressures on health and social care services have been suggested as one factor explaining these changes. This paper outlines a protocol for the approach to testing the extent to which health and social care pressures can explain recent mortality trends in Scotland. Although a slower rate of mortality improvements have affected people of all ages, certain ages have been more negatively affected than the others. The current analyses will be run by age-band to test if the service pressure-mortality link varies across age-group.Methods and analysisThis will be an observational ecological study based on the Scottish population. The exposures of interest will be the absolute (primary outcome) and percentage (secondary outcome) change in real terms per capita spending on social and healthcare services between 2011 and 2017. The outcome of interest will be the absolute (primary outcome) and percentage (secondary outcome) change in age-standardised mortality rate between 2012 and 2018 for men and women separately. The units of analysis will be the 32 local authorities and the 14 territorial health boards. The analyses will be run for both all age-groups combined and for the following age bands: <1, 1–15, 16–44, 45–64, 65–74, 75–84 and 85+.A series of descriptive analyses will summarise the distribution of health and social care expenditure and mortality trends between 2011 and 2018. Linear regression analysis will be used to investigate the direct association between health care spending and mortality rates.Ethics and disseminationThe data used in this study will be publicly available and aggregated and will not be individually identifiable; therefore, ethical committee approval is not needed. This work will not result in the creation of a new data set. On completion, the study will be stored within the National Health Service research governance system. All of the results will be published once they have been shared with partner agencies.

Overlooking the front line: Impacts of front‐line worker inclusion on implementation and outcomes of collaborative innovation

“…To put the extent of Scotland's wicked problem of demographic change into context, it is projected that the retired population of Scotland will increase by 27% from 2012 to 2037 and the working age population by 4% (Audit Scotland, 2016; Wraw et al, 2020). Healthcare in Scotland is devolved from the UK parliament and provided by 14 regional health boards (SPICe, 2016).…”

Ownership Variation in Violated Regulations and National Care Standards: Evidence From Social Care Providers

“…However, for competition to improve social care services, it is central that the commissioning system under which these are contracted consider potential flaws in the incentive structure. It is known that social care budgets in the United Kingdom are decreasing (Glasby et al, 2020;Wraw et al, 2020) and quasi-markets have been accused of outsourcing austerity and reduced social care budgets to nongovernmental providers (Hudson, 2016). If contracts are primarily awarded according to outcomes such as costs, it follows that these will then be the focus of providers in a competitive environment, which may have harmful effects in the long run.…”