Calciphylaxis, or calcific uremic arteriolopathy, is a rare and deadly disease that affects patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD). It typically manifests in the abdomen and lower extremities. We present a case of a 59-year-old female patient on dialysis due to ESRD who complained of a three-week history of hemorrhagic and painful bilateral lower limb lesions. The predominant clinical suspicion was warfarin-induced skin necrosis (WISN); however, the persistence of unresolved skin lesions post-warfarin cessation generated the impression of calciphylaxis. A skin biopsy confirmed the classical histological findings associated with calciphylaxis. This paper highlights the possible importance of warfarin being an inciting event, as well as the early differentiation between the presentations of WISN and calciphylaxis.