This exploratory qualitative research focuses on the experiences of those who facilitate lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer/questioning (LGBTQ+) social justice educational interventions (SJEIs), such as safe zone, safe space, and ally training. Although persistent in higher education LGBTQ+ SJEIs remain an understudied area for empirical research, especially how facilitators describe the benefits and challenges of this role. Findings reveal how these benefits and challenges are paradoxical in that participants are hopeful for the impact of the work while burdened by the endeavor. Implications illuminate how participants approach engagement with campus communities through SJEIs as a potential opportunity for increasing inclusion efforts and how participants act as tempered radicals within this facilitator role in higher education.