Building on student mathematical thinking in whole-class discourse: exploring teachers’ in-the-moment decision-making, interpretation, and underlying conceptions

Abstract

Often, mathematics teachers do not incorporate whole-class discourse of students’ various ideas and solution methods into their teaching practice. Particularly complex is the in-the-moment decision-making that is necessary to build on students’ thinking and develop their collective construction of mathematics. This study explores the decision-making patterns of five experienced Dutch mathematics teachers during their novice attempts at orchestrating whole-class discourse concerning students’ various solution methods. Our goal has been to unpack the complexity of their in-the-moment decision-making during whole-class discourse through lesson observations and stimulated recall interviews. We investigated teacher decision-making adopting a model that combines two perspectives, namely (1) we explored student-teacher interaction with regard to building on student thinking and (2) we explored how the teachers based decisions during such interaction upon their own personal conceptions and interpretation of student thinking. During these novice attempts at orchestrating whole-class discourse, the teachers created many situations for students to articulate their thinking. We found that at certain instances, teachers’ in-the-moment decision-making resulted in opportunities to build on student thinking that were not completely seized. During such instances, the teachers’ decision-making was shaped by the teachers’ own conceptions of the relevant mathematics and by teacher conceptions that centered around student understanding and mathematical goals. Our findings suggest that teachers might be supported in their novice attempts at whole-class discourse by explicit discussion of the mathematics and of their conceptions with regard to student understanding and mathematical goals.

The bridging understanding of language and mathematical symbols between teachers and students: An effort to increase mathematical literacy

“…The humans (students) interpret mathematics by building their conceptions (Kooloos et al, 2022). Some students may not realize that problematic conceptions arise if the connection with previous understandings does not take context into account.…”

The Indonesian Independent Curriculum Requires Student-Centred Teaching Approaches: Does the Teacher Guide Accompanying a Grade VIII Ministry-Published Mathematics Textbook Assist Teachers?

“…Nevertheless, if more Let Us Work Together and Let Us Communicate sections of the textbook had an additional explanation in the teacher guide about how to use them, teachers could get support from the teacher guide to guide students working on these sections. Guidance from teachers can help students develop their mathematical thinking, either to think critically or to think creatively (Kooloos, Oolbekkink-Marchand, van Boven, Kaenders, & Heckman, 2022).…”

Oral Questioning Strategies of Mathematics Teachers in Teaching and Learning Mathematics: A Systematic Literature Review

“…On the other hand, teacher follow-up plays a very important role (Dong et al, 2017;Kooloos et al, 2021;Lim et al, 2020). The teacher's follow-up action stimulates students to think and understand more deeply about the mathematical problem.…”