Building Cognition: The Construction of Computational Representations for Scientific Discovery

Abstract

Novel computational representations, such as simulation models of complex systems and video games for scientific discovery (Foldit, EteRNA etc.), are dramatically changing the way discoveries emerge in science and engineering. The cognitive roles played by such computational representations in discovery are not well understood. We present a theoretical analysis of the cognitive roles such representations play, based on an ethnographic study of the building of computational models in a systems biology laboratory. Specifically, we focus on a case of model-building by an engineer that led to a remarkable discovery in basic bioscience. Accounting for such discoveries requires a distributed cognition (DC) analysis, as DC focuses on the roles played by external representations in cognitive processes. However, DC analyses by-and-large have not examined scientific discovery, and mostly focus on memory offloading, particularly how the use of existing external representations change the nature of cognitive tasks. In contrast, we study discovery processes, and argue that discoveries emerge from the processes of building the computational representation. The building process integrates manipulations in imagination and in the representation, creating a coupled cognitive system of model and modeler, where the model is incorporated into the modeler's imagination. This account extends DC significantly, and we present some of its theoretical and application implications.

User studies in cartography: opportunities for empirical research on interactive maps and visualizations

“…Furthermore, there are a number of qualitative techniques emerging from cognitive science that have direct applicability to the study of interactive maps and visualizations (e.g. Chandrasekharan & Nersessian, 2011;Davies, Goel, & Nersessian, 2009;Harmon & Nersessian, 2008). Finally, qualitative and mixed-method research is now a staple for user studies in interactive cartography -particularly in the requirements analysis stage of UCD studies (e.g.…”

Thoughtful artificial intelligence: Forging a new partnership for data science and scientific discovery

“…Ongoing work in cognitive science and philosophy of science is articulating such processes [5]. We need to incorporate them in artificial intelligence systems.…”

Experimental effects and causal representations

“…Worth noting is that such a discussion will require drawing on literature in distributed cognition as it relates to scientific practice as well as the nature of cognition. For example, Giere (2006) discusses cognition being distributed in scientific modeling; and Chandrasekharan and Nersessian (2015) discuss how representations changes the nature of cognitive tasks while building computational models in the laboratory. The second interesting point about Ihde's concept of 'embodiment relations' is about the focus on relations rather than objects.…”