Building back better? – negotiating normative boundaries of gender mainstreaming and post-tsunami reconstruction in Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam, Indonesia

Abstract

This article focuses on gender mainstreaming policies and advocacy on gender equality in the post-tsunami context in Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam. Through the analysis, this article illustrates how gender mainstreaming policy documents and gender advocacy of the provincial and central government, when drawing from sex/gender division and binary of genders, reproduce heteronormative boundaries. By focusing on details, I argue that the image of the heteronormative nuclear family participates in normalising other identity categories; such as urban and middle-class. I also provide examples of how simultaneous to the production of dominant norms, gender advocacy challenges heteronormativity and norms governing heterosexuality and actively question the dominant gender norms. Drawing from postcolonial feminist and recent queer critiques, I argue that advocacy that solely focuses on gender and/or sexuality reduces human bodies and their desires to simplistic stick figures. Thus, it remains blind to other forms of violence, such as global economic and political frameworks that define ‘building back better’ primarily as recovery and rehabilitation of economy, assets and labour force.

Queer International Relations

“…LGBT subjects. For example, Queer IR has revealed security problems faced by LGBT people that are rendered invisible even in feminist analyses of human security , sexual and gender-based violence , and post-conflict reconstruction (Jauhola, 2010(Jauhola, , 2013McEvoy, 2015). Both feminist and non-feminist analyses of International…”

Feminist Change Revisited: Gender Mainstreaming as Slow Revolution

“…The link between gender as diagnosis calling for gender mainstreaming and the eventual emphasis on women as outcome reflects an understanding of gender in two kinds of binary oppositions, both in their own way problematic. One is the rather rigid division between sex and gender, the other being gender as translated into two opposing sexes, men and women (Delphy, ; Jauhola, ; Zalewski, ). Gender has been institutionalised and normalised within different domains of society, such as popular culture and also in governance.…”

Navigating an inconvenient difference in antagonistic contexts: Doing fieldwork in Aceh, Indonesia

“…Both the Helsinki agreement and the LoGA intended to balance the centre‐periphery grievances between the main stakeholders in this conflict, the Gerakan Aceh Merdeka (GAM or Free Aceh Movement) and the central government of Indonesia (Drexler, ; Aspinall, ). In parallel with these internal negotiations, Aceh experienced a massive foreign involvement and humanitarian aid following the tsunami, bringing further dramatic cultural and economic changes to local people not only in Aceh (Hyndman, ; Jauhola, ; Waizenegger & Hyndman, ; Zeccola, ; Hyndman, ; Phelps et al, ; Jordan & Stange, ), but also in the neighbouring countries (Nah & Bunnell, ) and among the Acehnese diaspora (Missbach, ).…”