Building a Venture Capital Market in Vietnam: Diffusion of a Neoliberal Market Strategy to a Socialist State

Abstract

Vietnam's venture capital (VC) industry took shape in the late 1990s during a period of exceptional economic growth in the country and the development of its high-technology sector. High growth rates and technological advances have typically coincided with both strong VC market activity and state support of equity financing. This, however, has not been the case in Vietnam. In this article a policy diffusion framework is used to investigate the international and domestic origins of Vietnam's nascent VC policies, and how they became part of the agenda of the Communist Party of Vietnam (CPV) as credit-based, rather than equity-based, solutions. The article argues that Vietnam's heterodox approach to VC policy results from both external forces from donors and from domestic factors. In particular, Vietnamese policymakers have a preference for credit-based SME financing solutions and Vietnam's official development assistance providers diffuse expertise on loans, not equity investments, to the Socialist Republic. The only donors recommending VC and equity-based financing in Vietnam have gone "around the state" rather than through it by working directly with the private sector. As a result, Vietnam's SME financing initiatives have significantly diverged from international VC policy patterns.

Science and Technology Policies and the Middle-Income Trap: Lessons from Vietnam

“…Intel decided to invest in Vietnam as it scaled down testing and assembly in its China facility, for reasons of rising costs and fear of intellectual property theft. It chose Vietnam thanks to the efforts of a returnee who had worked at Intel's Santa Clara headquarters for fifteen years, and then lobbied top management to agree to the investment, under his management (Klingler-Vidra, 2014b). Intel came at its own initiative, without much courting by government.…”

An institutional analysis of the fiscal autonomy of public hospitals in Vietnam

“…Since then, the international community has been very active in its support for Vietnam's capacity building and development needs. Official development assistance is the country's significant source of finance, accounting for one third of the state's public budget (Klingler‐Vidra, ). The international community especially focuses its assistance on Vietnam's transition to a market economy with 63% of the total aid allocated to the economic sector and 14% to governance reform during 2000–09 (OECD, ).…”

“…The development assistance in Vietnam pushed the country to take policy prescriptions from international donors as a condition for funding (Klingler‐Vidra, ). In governance reform, the development assistance from such donors as World Bank, International Monetary Fund, and United Nations Development Programme has particularly aimed at accelerating the process of decentralisation from central to local government and autonomisation within public sector organisations including state‐owned enterprises (SOEs) and public service delivery units (PSDUs).…”

The Vietnamese financial economy: reforms and development, 1986-2016

“…Due to the predominant credit-based financing agenda by the Vietnamese government, venture-capital activities had a slow start in the 1990s, and Vietnam's entrepreneurial financing initiatives have significantly diverged from international venturecapital policy patterns (Klingler-Vidra 2014 In 2015, the government also explored the opportunity of setting up a VCF to support newborn ecosystem for tech-related entrepreneurs, with assistance from statefinanced sci-tech supports agencies such as NAFOSTED/NATIF/NATEC, Vietnam Startup Fund, and Vietnam Silicon Valley Project. Still, there is a lack of local funds so that earlystage tech startups are underfinanced.…”