Bringing creative psychotherapies to primary NHS Mental Health Services in the UK: A feasibility study on patient and staff experiences of arts for the blues workshops delivered at Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) services

Abstract

There have been several arguments for the need to generate evidence‐based creative forms of psychological interventions in Improving Access to Psychological Services (IAPT), the main primary mental health provider in hospitals in England, UK. In this feasibility study, we sought to identify helpful and unhelpful factors of a new creative group psychotherapy, titled Arts for the Blues. We also wanted to find out whether the research tools used were acceptable and sensitive. We therefore engaged a group of seven patients attending an IAPT service in the North West of England, and a group of six staff working in the same service, to attend one creative workshop each, followed by a focus group. The two focus groups were transcribed and analysed using thematic analysis. We also collected pre‐ and post‐measures of depression (PHQ‐9) and anxiety (GAD‐7), measures commonly used in IAPT services, plus measures of well‐being (WHO‐5), the PANAS, and goal‐setting, which were considered for acceptability and sensitivity. We received largely positive responses from service users and staff in the use of creative methods in psychotherapy. Although the measures used had limitations due to the short duration of one‐off creative workshops, we found that they were sensitive enough, easy to complete and, thus, were acceptable. We concluded that Arts for the Blues is a promising intervention in IAPT, especially since it is shaped by service users and staff working in these services. Further work is needed to establish the effectiveness of this new intervention.

Navigating the Storm to Recovery through the Pictorial Representations of Persons in the Recovery Phase from Unipolar Depression

“…People who have experienced depression often describe the difficulty to communicate their experiences, such as feelings of emptiness and dysfunctional thoughts in words [ 7 ]. However, the use of imagery may assist in the communication of their experiences, whilst also providing experiential relief and cathartic expression [ 15 ].…”

High temperatures on mental health: Recognizing the association and the need for proactive strategies—A perspective

“…Individuals may acquire the ability to recognize and alter destructive patterns of thought and action through cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) 63 . For those experiencing severe anxiety or depressive symptoms due to heat stress, talking therapies can offer a safe space to explore feelings and develop coping strategies 64 . In addition, therapists can assist in adapting treatment regimens for patients with pre‐existing mental health disorders who are particularly susceptible to heat 65 .…”

“… 63 For those experiencing severe anxiety or depressive symptoms due to heat stress, talking therapies can offer a safe space to explore feelings and develop coping strategies. 64 In addition, therapists can assist in adapting treatment regimens for patients with pre‐existing mental health disorders who are particularly susceptible to heat. 65 It is essential to consult with a healthcare provider or a mental health professional to discuss the most appropriate therapy or counseling options.…”

Developing a strategy to scale up place-based arts initiatives that support mental health and wellbeing: A realist evaluation of ‘Arts for the Blues’

“…The intervention was originally designed to address the needs of users of primary mental health services and specifically NHS Talking Therapies services. We aimed to offer an additional option to service users that could tackle depression in deprived communities in inner city Manchester [ 15 ]. Since then, we have piloted the work with adults in local mental health charities and with children in school settings in the North West.…”