We have conducted mechanistic investigations
using dispersion-corrected
hybrid density functional theory on three different homogeneous processes:
(a) hydrogenation of styrene using H2, (b) dehydrogenation
of amine–borane, and (c) transfer hydrogenation of styrene
using amine–borane catalyzed by a boryl-ligated Co-based catalytic
system, LCo(N2) (where L = meridional bis-phosphinoboryl
(PBP) ligand), recently developed by Peters and co-workers (Lin, T.-P;
Peters, J. C. J. Am. Chem. Soc.
2013, 135, 15310–15313). Our studies reveal that
all three catalytic processes are facilitated by the same active species,
which is of the form LCo(H)2. The formation of the active
catalytic species in turn determines the rate-determining barrier
(RDB) for the hydrogenation reactions of the olefin and also for the
dehydrogenation reaction of amine–borane. We predict that the
RDB for hydrogenation of styrene under H2 atmosphere is
17.3 kcal/mol, which occurs through a channel that involves switching
of a singlet electronic ground state (S0) of the organometallic
catalytic species to its low-lying triplet electronic state (T1) and returning back to the singlet surface through minimum
energy crossing points along the reaction coordinate. Alternatively,
we estimate the RDB to be 19.4 kcal/mol, slightly higher than that
of the previous channel, if only the singlet spin state surface is
considered. We find that the associated RDB for both the dehydrogenation
of amine–borane (NMe2H-BH3) and transfer
hydrogenation of styrene by amine–borane are higher than the
hydrogenation of olefin using H2(g) and is predicted to
be 24.7 kcal/mol. In addition, we show that in the reaction involving
amine–borane, the active catalytic species (LCo(H)2) can get deactivated by forming a hydridoborane cobalt tetrahydridoborate
complex, which happens through an SN2 type nucleophilic
attack by the LCo(H)2 on amine–borane.