Breakdown of universal Lindemann criterion in the melting of Lennard-Jones polydisperse solids

Abstract

It is commonly believed that melting occurs when mean square displacement (MSD) of a particle of crystalline solid exceeds a threshold value. This is known as the Lindemann criterion, first introduced in the year of 1910 by Lindemann. However, Chakravarty et al. demonstrated that this common wisdom is inadequate because the MSD at melting can be temperature dependent when pressure is also allowed to vary along the coexistence line of the phase diagram [Chakravarty C, Debenedetti P G and Stillinger F H 2007 J. Chem. Phys.126 204508]. We show here by extensive molecular dynamics simulation of both two and three dimensional polydisperse Lennard-Jones solids that particles on the small and large limits of size distribution exhibit substantially different Lindemann ratio at melting. Despite all the dispersion in MSD, melting is found to be first order in both the dimensions at 5-10% dispersity in size.

Monitoring the melting behavior of boron nanoparticles using a neural network potential

“…In general, a critical Linderman index value, 0.1, is regarded as the melting indicator. 61 By viewing the radial distributions of the atomic Lindeman index (Fig. 10f and g), the particle surface atoms exhibit a higher Lindemann index, reaching 0.15 at 1800 K. The surface atoms have smaller coordination numbers and greater energies than the atoms in the interior regions of the particle.…”

Melting Is Well-Known, but Is It Also Well-Understood?

“…This critical value saturates to a value of about 0.11 for all temperatures, in good agreement with the experimental value of 0.12. Further, it was shown that the Lindemann rule breaks down for polydisperse systems, 183 as the increased root-meansquare amplitude of the smaller particles plays a role in the segregation of them prior to melting, although melting itself remain discontinuous.…”

Phase change materials for thermal energy storage: A perspective on linking phonon physics to performance

“…Consequently, simple melting "rules" formulated from experimental observation have been popular. The Lindemann melting criterion [13][14][15] is perhaps the most widely used melting rule, and it states that melting occurs when the root mean amplitude of vibration exceeds a threshold value in relation to the nearest neighbor distance (originally stated to be 10%). At melt, all atoms vibrate at the Einstein frequency so the equipartition theorem can be used to equate the amplitude of vibration to the temperature, yielding 𝑇 ( =…”