The process by which the Saccharomyces cerevisiae strand transfer protein, Rad51, seeks out homologous sequences in vivo can be modeled by an in vitro reaction between a single-stranded DNA circle and a doublestranded linear DNA. In addition to the substrates and products, electrophoresis of reaction mixtures resolves two groups of low mobility bands. Here we show that the low mobility bands formed during strand transfer by Rad51 (or Escherichia coli RecA) represent joint molecules (JM) between the two substrates. One group, which we name JM1, is an obligatory reaction intermediate in which the complementary strand from the duplex substrate has been partially transferred to the single-stranded circle. Our assignment is based on pulse-chase and restriction enzyme digestion experiments and verified by electron microscopy. The slower moving group of bands, designated JM2, is formed by an unexpected reaction between JM1 and a second doublestranded linear substrate. Strand transfer of the second duplex initiates noncanonically from the end where the complementary strand is recessed. Thus JM2 is formed by two strand transfer reactions with the same singlestranded circular substrate but with opposite polarities. Finally, we show that the multiple sharp bands in JM1 and JM2 are the result of substrate sequences that pause strand transfer.During the initial steps of DNA double-strand break repair, a strand transfer protein such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rad51 forms a filament along the 3Ј single-stranded tails generated from broken DNA ends (1). The resulting nucleoprotein filament then searches the genome for sequences homologous to the tail that can serve as templates for the repair synthesis needed to restore the continuity of the chromosome (2). Rad51 is called a strand transfer protein because it catalyzes the invasion of the single-stranded tail into the intact template duplex and transfers base pairing interactions from the identical strand of the template duplex to the tail. The 3Ј end of the transferred tail can then serve as a primer for repair synthesis (3). The mechanisms of the homology search and subsequent strand transfer are not well understood. Indeed, it is difficult to imagine a process that achieves both the speed and fidelity with which a sequence homolog is found in vivo.The homology search process and the broader mechanism of strand transfer proteins have been studied using an in vitro strand transfer reaction that recapitulates the first steps of homologous recombination (4) (Fig. 1A). Whereas early work focused on the Escherichia coli RecA protein (5), the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rad51 protein has been favored for studies of recombination in eukaryotes (6, 7).In the model strand transfer reaction, Rad51 coats a singlestranded circular (ssC) 1 DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament that associates with a homologous double-stranded linear (dsL) DNA. Once the nucleoprotein filament has aligned the homologous partners in a paranemic joint, which involves no net intertwining of the substrate DNAs, st...