Bollywood as Witness: Changing Perceptions of Mental Illness in India (1913–2010)

Abstract

Indian cinema, affectionately known as Bollywood, makes more movies than Hollywood and is hugely influential in shaping social attitudes in the Indian subcontinent and many other parts of the world. In order to study depiction of mental illness, we searched anthology of Indian movies from 1930s up to the present. We divided this period into four arbitrary sections based on the broader political and socio-economic climate in India. Movie plots were analyzed and information about the attitudes towards mental illness, accuracy and depiction of mental illness and the treatment methods portrayed was extracted. The key findings of the study were that attitudes towards mental illness in Indian cinema paralleled the broader political and socio-economic trends in Indian society. In the age of political idealism, mental illness was portrayed as benign and amusing. With increasing political corruption and instability, mentally ill characters were depicted as cruel, deviant and psychopathic. The portrayal of mental illness is often inaccurate and exaggerated, keeping in line with the hyperbolic nature of Indian cinema. With increasing political and economic stabilization, attitudes are changing once again. Recent movies display more sympathy and understanding towards characters with mental illness.

Onnellinen mielisairaalapotilas? Poikkeavuus ja erilaisuuden rajankäynti elokuvassa Prinsessa

“…Nousukaudet korreloivat verrattain positiivisina mielisairauden ja -sairaiden representaatioina, epävarmuuden kaudet taas negatiivisina. (Bhugra 2005;Malik & al. 2011.…”

Hey Jude

“…While they have portrayed the plight of the mentally ill, they are many a time negative and stereotypical. 1,2 Given this scenario, Hey Jude, is unique in terms of the portrayal of mental illness in Malayalam cinema.…”

Schizophrenia, the Patient, the Caregiver and the Psychiatrist: Interrelationship in Bollywood films

“…Bhugra (2005) mentions that the portrayal of mental illnesses in films can be negative for a variety of reasons such as stigma, lack of knowledge and focus on entertainment rather than education. Malik et al (2011) points out that the portrayal of mental illnesses in Indian cinema paralleled the broader political and socio-economic trends in Indian society. If the main protagonist is mentally ill, the story usually highlights the breakdowns and relapses, absence of good treatment, inevitability of chronicity and finally poor outcome.…”