Black Boxes in Workplace Mathematics

Abstract

We ground Cultural-Historical Activity Theory (CHAT) in studies of workplace practices from a mathematical point of view. We draw on multiple case study visits by college students and teacher-researchers to workplaces. By asking questions that 'open boxes', we 'outsiders and boundary-crossers' sought to expose contradictions between College and work, induce breakdowns and identify salient mathematics. Typically, we find that mathematical processes have been historically crystallised in 'black boxes' shaped by workplace cultures: its instruments, rules and divisions of labour tending to disguise or hide mathematics. These black boxes are of two kinds, signalling two key processes by which mathematics is put to work. The first involves automation, when the work of mathematics is crystallised in instruments, tools and routines: this process tends to distribute and hide mathematical work, but also evolves a distinct workplace 'genre' of mathematical practice. The second process involves sub-units of the community being protected from mathematics by a division of labour supported by communal rules, norms and expectations. These are often regulated by boundary objects that are the object of activity on one side of the boundary but serve as instruments of activity on the other side. We explain contradictions between workplace and College practices in analyses of the contrasting functions of the activity systems that structure them and that consequently provide for different genres and distributions of mathematics, and finally draw inferences for better alignment of College programmes with the needs of students.

Re-thinking science capital: the role of ‘capital’ and ‘identity’ in mediating students’ engagement with mathematically demanding programmes at university

“…For instance, Stacey sees mathematics as deeply embedded in the Physics she loves and so it has use value in enabling one to see the world in a particular way. This resonates with a large body of work on 'modelling' as a powerful example of how the use value of mathematics can be fostered in pedagogic/mathematical practice (Williams and Wake, 2007; Wake this issue).…”

What Mathematics Education May Prepare Students for the Society of the Future?

“…With complex mathematics hidden in technological black boxes, it is imperative that the worker understands the mathematical calculations enough to create the input and interpret the output of the technology (Kent, Noss, Guile, Hoyles & Bakker, 2007;Gainsburg, 2007). Employees must also be able to communicate the black box mathematics to their peers and bosses (Williams & Wake, 2007b). Given the necessity of communicating the mathematics hidden within technological black boxes, it is not surprising that employers see communication and critical thinking as one of the most essential skills they seek in college graduates (Hoyles, Wolf, Kent & Molyneux-Hodgson, 2002).…”

The use, nature and purposes of measurement in intermediate-level occupations

“…Williams & Wake, 2007). Latour (1999, p. 304) pointed to the paradox of technology as black boxes: scientific and technical work is made invisible by its own success.…”