Bird Pollinator Visitation is Equivalent in Island and Plantation Planting Designs in Tropical Forest Restoration Sites

Abstract

Active restoration is one strategy to reverse tropical forest loss. Given the dynamic nature of climates, human populations, and other ecosystem components, the past practice of using historical reference sites as restoration targets is unlikely to result in selfsustaining ecosystems. Restoring sustainable ecological processes like pollination is a more feasible goal. We investigated how flower cover, planting design, and landscape forest cover influenced bird pollinator visits to Inga edulis trees in young restoration sites in Costa Rica. I. edulis trees were located in island plantings, where seedlings had been planted in patches, or in plantation plantings, where seedlings were planted to cover the restoration area. Sites were located in landscapes with scant (10-21%) or moderate (35-76%) forest cover. Trees with greater flower cover received more visits from pollinating birds; neither planting design nor landscape forest cover influenced the number of pollinator visits. Resident hummingbirds and a migratory bird species were the most frequent bird pollinators. Pollination in the early years following planting may not be as affected by details of restoration design as other ecological processes like seed dispersal. Future work to assess the quality of various pollinator species will be important in assessing this idea. OPEN ACCESSSustainability 2013, 5 1178

Neotropical rainforest restoration: comparing passive, plantation and nucleation approaches

“…Although plantations foster greater bird abundance and compositional similarity to old-growth forest than applied nucleation designs (Reid et al 2014;Vogel et al 2015), Vogel et al (2015) showed that Brazilian nucleation techniques facilitated exclusive species with higher richness and abundance (in disagree with Reid et al 2014). Overall, it is argued that applied nucleation facilitates pollinator visitation and tree recruitment to a similar degree as plantations, but with lower costs Lindell and Thurston 2013;Zahawi et al 2013). The nucleation approach may assist the natural assembly processes which should govern recovery (Corbin and Holl 2012;Holl et al 2013;Reis et al 2010).…”

Pollination of a bee‐dependent forb in restored prairie: no evidence of pollen limitation in landscapes dominated by row crop agriculture

“…The few other studies directly measuring the effect of landscape‐scale factors on pollinator abundance or pollination in restorations have also not detected a strong relationship. A study examining pollination of Inga edulis (ice‐cream‐bean; Mart., Fabaceae) in restored forests found no effect of surrounding forest on pollinator visitation rates (Lindell & Thurston ). Similarly, a study of heathlands found pollination function (measured through a pollen transport network) was similar between restored and remnant heathlands, regardless of a restoration's proximity to remnant heathland (Forup et al ).…”

Frugivoria de Peixes em Áreas Úmidas Neotropicais: Passado, Presente e Futuro de uma Interação Única

“…Reforestation of degraded Amazonian and Pantanal floodplains represents an opportunity to restore ecosystem function and services in these megadiverse wetlands (Chazdon 2008, Lindell and Thurston 2013, Mukul et al 2016. Floodplain forest fruits are commonly used as fishing bait by local fishers (Wittmann and Wittmann 2010).…”