Biophysical sustainability, process-based monitoring and forest ecosystem management decision support systems

Abstract

Sustainability is a key concept in resource management and environmental issues, but implementation is fraught with difficulty due to lack of agreement as to what it means. Because of the ubiquity of disturbance, ecosystem sustainability inevitably involves change. We define stand-level biophysical sustainability as non-declining patterns of change over at least three cycles of disturbance, and landscape-level sustainability as a shifting mosaic of non-declining stand change, the overall character of which remains within acceptable limits over time. Simple empirical assessment (i.e., monitoring) of this concept of sustainability is generally not practical in forestry because of the long time and large spatial scales involved. Adaptive management (AM), another key resource management concept, involves monitoring to assess the consequences of management actions. It requires forecasts of expected change in sustainably managed, post-disturbance ecosystems against which to assess monitoring data. Without these forecasts, which constitute temporal fingerprints of sustainable change, short-term monitoring data cannot be used reliably as a basis from which to assess longer-term sustainability. A comprehensive monitoring system to address biophysical sustainability locally and at the landscape scale for a large management unit over a rotation-length time scale would involve the key elements of ecosystem structure and function and the effects thereon of management and climate change. This would be prohibitively expensive and demanding of human resources and the results would not be available until the end of the rotation. A strategy that honours the intent of AM is an intimate linkage between predictive monitoring and process-based ecosystem management decision support systems-ecosystem process-based monitoring-the emphasis of which is on temporal patterns of indicator change rather than comparisons between static indicators and audits of current ecosystem conditions (the certification approach). It involves a combination of monitoring and ecosystem management modeling that reduces the long-term cost of monitoring and increases the utility of the data collected for the assessment of sustainability and for the design of policy and adaptive practice in forestry.Key words: prediction, process-based monitoring, sustainability, forest ecosystems, biophysical indicators, temporal fingerprints, adaptive management, ecosystem management models RÉSUMÉ La durabilité est un concept clé de l'aménagement des ressources et des enjeux environnementaux, mais son implantation présente de multiples difficultés du fait de l'absence d'entente sur sa signification. Compte tenu de l'ubiquité liée aux perturbations, la durabilité d'un écosystème implique obligatoirement des changements. Nous définissons la durabilité biophysique au niveau du peuplement comme étant des patrons non successifs de changement au cours d'au moins trois cycles de perturbations, et la durabilité au niveau de l'écosystème comme étant une mosaïque progressive de ...

Evaluation of the effects of forest management strategies on carbon sequestration in evergreen broad-leaved (Phoebe bournei) plantation forests using FORECAST ecosystem model

“…Since soil organic matter is essential to ecosystem productivity and regeneration, the maintenance of adequate levels of soil organic matter should be an integral component of soil management strategies (Morris et al, 1997;Seely et al, 2010 ). The concept of ecological rotation, defined as the time required for an element of an ecosystem to recover near its original state following a disturbance event, provides a useful framework for assessing the effects of forest managemen t practices on long-term soil productivity (Kimmins, 1974;Kimmins et al, 2007 ). However, a decline in ecosystem productivity will likely take place if the anticipated economic rotation for a particular site is shorter than the associated ecological rotation.…”

From guiding principles for the conservation of forest biodiversity to on-ground practice: Lessons from tree hollow management in Tasmania

“…Assessing the effectiveness of a forest practices system in relation to a particular element of biodiversity is an extremely difficult task (Kimmins et al, 2007) and made more difficult by the lack of measurable objectives or desired outcomes. Unfortunately the piece-meal nature of many of the monitoring studies and their lack of a contextual framework e.g.…”

A concept in adaptive ecosystem management—An engineering perspective

“…Although disturbances such as storms, insect calamities or fire have been accepted as a major driver of ecosystems development (Levin, 1998;Kimmins et al, 2007), there is still a very limited understanding of the dose-response behavior, induced by a variety of strains. The concept of risk analysis has its roots in engineering sciences, from where it spread to the management of natural and social hazards.…”

“…Additionally, the best practices have been specified for whole stand rotation-cycles (management regimes) and interventions at specific stages of stand development (management prescriptions). However, there have been major concerns if past experience will be a reliable basis for policy and management decisions under a changing and uncertain future (Kimmins et al, 2007). The main problem to tackle with is that no one can know the exact consequences of any portfolio of policies and practices beforehand (Prins and Rayner, 2007).…”

“…sustained yield approach has been widely replaced by concern over sustainability of the entire ecological system, consisting of ecosystem structures, functions, goods and services (Kimmins et al, 2007). Forest sciences aimed at developing the best policies and best practices for stand management by ex-post analysis of observational and experimental data.…”