“…In coccolithophores, for example, calcification rates were repeatedly shown to increase from low to intermediate DIC but decrease again above certain thresholds (Langer et al, 2006;Bach et al, 2011Bach et al, , 2015Sett et al, 2014). This optimumcurve response pattern was explained by the interaction between HCO − 3 and protons (H + ), where HCO − 3 stimulates calcification as substrate and H + functions as inhibitor (Bach et al, 2011(Bach et al, , 2013. Similar conclusions have also been made in studies with bivalves (Thomsen et al, 2015) and corals (Jury et al, 2010), where it has been noted that the calcification response to changing carbonate chemistry could be the result of the opposing effects of and [H + ].…”