Despite the frequency of rotator cuff tendinopathies, rotator cuff repair procedures still have high failure rates. Thus, new treatment strategies that accelerate healing and improve regeneration are needed. Tissue engineering approaches, which include the implantation of extracellular matrix scaffolds, cells, and/or growth factors, can be applied to modulate the healing process, improving biomechanical properties and functional outcomes of the repaired tendon. In particular, the microstructural properties of extracellular matrix scaffolds can influence cell migration, protein synthesis, and fiber organization in healing tendon. Through manufacturing techniques, such as three-dimensional printing, the properties of these scaffolds can be optimized for rotator cuff regeneration. In addition to scaffolds, implantation of stem cells and tenocytes has been shown to increase healing rates and reduce inflammation in animal models but has not been tested clinically. Many growth factors also are present at the wound site during healing, but studies attempting to recreate these conditions during healing with platelet-rich plasma have found little evidence supporting its use. Systematic treatments, including anti-inflammatory medication and metalloproteinase inhibitors, are commonly used in rotator cuff tendinopathies but have adverse effects that inhibit tendon healing. A variety of tissue engineering and biologic treatments for rotator cuff tendinopathy are currently being developed, but challenges still remain before they can be applied clinically.