“…However, determining mineralogy using EDS only can be contentious, as hydrogen sulfide can potentially adsorb onto iron sulfide aggregates, and thus alter the measured Fe:S ratio of the precipitates. X-ray diffraction (XRD), selected area electron diffraction (SAED), or X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), revealed primarily the formation of mackinawite and greigite in microbial cultures to which Fe has been provided as soluble Fe(II) ( Table 1) (Rickard, 1969;Herbert et al, 1998;Benning et al, 1999;Watson et al, 2000;Neal et al, 2001;Li et al, 2004;Williams et al, 2005;Gramp et al, 2009Gramp et al, , 2010Zhou et al, 2014). While greigite is typically found as rod-shaped and 100-to 300-nm platelet structures (Herbert et al, 1998;Gramp et al, 2010), mackinawite does not have a specific morphology, and both minerals appear (via XRD and SEM) to be disordered and poorly crystalline and tend to assemble in µm-sized aggregates (Fortin et al, 1994;Herbert et al, 1998;Benning et al, 1999;Watson et al, 2000;Kim et al, 2015).…”