Bioarchaeological investigation of sharp force injuries to the ribs and lower leg from the battle of Stoney Creek in the War of 1812

Abstract

Sharp force trauma to the skeleton is an important source of evidence for violent injury in the past. Lesions attributable to possible perimortem sharp force injury were observed in 20 fragments within disarticulated and commingled human bone from the Smith's Knoll collection, an assemblage associated with the battle of Stoney Creek (1813, southern Ontario, Canada). Following analysis, questions remained surrounding lesions on fragments of the ribs and one distal fibula (SK0129). To better evaluate which injuries to the ribs were perimortem and what weapon is likely to have caused the injury to the fibula, faunal proxies were constructed and experimental lesions created using period replicas of a sword and a triangular socket bayonet. Similarities between the archaeological rib lesions and experimentally produced bayonet injuries indicate that 14 of the 38 lesions present in the rib fragments likely represent perimortem injuries. Two possible scenarios involving the sword and triangular socket bayonet were tested to determine the likely cause of the injury on the fibula. This injury displayed significant differences in appearance from the experimentally produced bayonet lesions on the replica lower leg, and was observed to correspond closely with characteristics associated with sword injuries described in the literature. This indicates that the lesion more likely represents the result of a sword stroke. Consideration of these injuries in the context of historical documentation regarding soldier experience during the battle of Stoney Creek helps to explain the apparently unusual placement of sharp force injuries within the skeleton of the individuals in the Smith's Knoll collection. This sample provides a unique opportunity for an evaluation of archaeological lesions that incorporates historical, experimental, and osteoarchaeological evidence, allowing a more nuanced understanding of violent injury in the past.

Forensic Veterinary Pathology

“…17 Upon exhumation of an animal killed with a sharp instrument, examination of the remains may reveal bone fractures and marks left by the instruments in the same manner that occurs in humans. 8,50,86…”

“…17 Upon exhumation of an animal killed with a sharp instrument, examination of the remains may reveal bone fractures and marks left by the instruments in the same manner that occurs in humans. 8,50,86 Animal dismemberment is not common but may occur for ritualistic purposes or meat consumption. In some cases, in addition to the utilization of axes or machetes, the dismemberment may also be performed using a saw (Fig.…”

“Buck and Ball”: Identification and interpretation of buckshot injuries to the pelvis from the War of 1812

“…The Smith's Knoll collection was examined for skeletal evidence of traumatic injuries sustained during the battle, revealing lesions relating to perimortem fracture, sharp force, and projectile trauma (Lockau, 2012;Lockau et al, 2013). Potential musket injuries were observed in three fragments of innominate (pelvis).…”