Big data analytics and auditor judgment: an experimental study

Abstract

Purpose Auditors’ skills and knowledge of data analytics and big data can influence their judgment at the audit planning stage. At this stage, the auditor will determine the level of audit risk and estimate how long the audit will take. This study aims to test whether big data and data analytics affect auditors’ judgment by adopting the cognitive fit theory. Design/methodology/approach This was an experimental study involving 109 accounting students as participants. The 2 × 2 factorial design between subjects in a laboratory setting was applied to test the hypothesis. Findings First, this study supports the proposed hypothesis that participants who are provided with visual analytics information will rate audit risk lower than text analytics. Second, participants who receive information on unstructured data types will assess audit risk (audit hours) higher (longer) than those receiving structured data types. In addition, those who receive information from visual analytics results have a higher level of reliance than those receiving text analytics. Practical implications This research has implications for external and internal auditors to improve their skills and knowledge of data analytics and big data to make better judgments, especially when the auditor is planning the audit. Originality/value Previous studies have examined the effect of data analytics (predictive vs anomaly) and big data (financial vs non-financial) on auditor judgment, whereas this study examined data analytics (visual vs text analytics) and big data (structured and unstructured), which were not tested in previous studies.

The School-ties Between Top Management Executive and Audit Partner: Exploring From Earnings Management in Indonesia

“…Research has demonstrated that school ties can play a role in facilitating access to valuable resources, information, and employment prospects. Particularly within the labor market, school ties have been shown to improve the effectiveness of connecting employers with suitable employees, while also fostering social cohesion and trust within the workplace (Sihombing et al, 2023). However, the potential negative consequences of school-ties have also been documented.…”

Influence of blockchain and artificial intelligence on audit quality: Evidence from Turkey

“…AI can automate repetitive and time-consuming audit tasks, such as data entry, data validation, and documentation. This automation reduces the risk of human error and allows auditors to focus on more complex and judgment-based activities [ 41 ]. [ 42 ] has shown that the automation of routine tasks through AI can enhance audit quality by improving accuracy, increasing efficiency, and freeing up auditors' time for higher-value activities.…”

AI-generated Information: What is the financial Reporting Framework?.

“…al., 2020) In the third procedure, the preselected, cleaned, and aggregated data undergo analysis using AI technology, characterized by sophisticated algorithms and high computing speed. This analysis aims to identify patterns and trends that may be significant for managerial purposes or external use by customers and partners, resulting in the extraction of intelligent information (Pei, D. and Vasarhelyi, 2020;Sihombing, 2023) The transformation of Big Data into AI-generated information necessitates economic resources, including IT infrastructure such as a database management system (DBMS) (de Villiers, 2024); data analytics…”

“…As a result of technological development and the digital economic environment for business models, the importance of obtaining highquality data and information generated by artificial intelligence that is useful in the decision-making process and achieving a competitive advantage has increased (Cockcroft, et. Al., 2018;Sihombing, 2023). Organizations gather and generate vast quantities of diverse data forms from various sources, commonly referred to as "Big Data," as part of their routine business activities.…”

“…Due to the current practices and regulatory frameworks, data might fit the criteria of an economic resource. However, -potential‖ is an undefined legal term giving possibility for interpretation and ambiguity (Beerbaum, 2019;Sihombing, 2023;de Villiers, 2024).…”