Beyond proximity: Consequentialist Ethics and System Dynamics

Abstract

<p>Consequentialism is a moral philosophy that maintains that the moral worth of an action is determined by the consequences it has for the welfare of a society. Consequences of model design are a part of the model lifecycle that is often neglected. This paper investigates the issue using system dynamics modeling as an example. Since a system dynamics model is a product of the modeler’s design decisions, the modeler should consider the life cycle consequences of using the model. Seen from a consequentialist perspective, the consequences of policies developed from system dynamics models determine the model’s moral value (ethical/unethical). This concept is explored by discussing model uncertainty from an engineering perspective. In this perspective, the ethical considerations shift from the behavior of the modeler (and away from validation) to the model itself and the model’s inherent uncertainty. When the ethical considerations are taken away from the modeler and directed to what the model does, the ethical boundaries extend beyond the proximity of the model. This discussion renews the ethics conversation in system dynamics by considering this shift in philosophical perspective, and investigates how consequentialist moral philosophy applies to the modeling process and in communicating with decision-makers. A model of social assistance in Norway in the context of immigration pressures illustrates some possibilities for addressing these ethical concerns. This paper argues for an ethical framework, or at the very least, an ethical conversation within the field of system dynamics.</p><p><span>Article first published online: 25 FEB 2017</span></p>

Ethical considerations of using system dynamics in participatory settings: a social‐ecological‐systems perspective

“…sustainability principles). Pruyt and Kwakkel (2007) and Palmer (2017) offer a set of ethical questions to guide the implementation of a system dynamics assessment. However, it is important that these questions are asked following a logical order.…”

The Ethics of Agent-Based Social Simulation

“…Some texts approach computer simulation relying on particular ethical accounts. Palmer (2017), for example, explicitly reframes the model evaluation process within consequentialist ethics. Others incorporate ethics more narrowly through specific morally relevant concepts e.…”

A multi-scale integrated assessment model to support urban sustainability

“…The modeller has a duty to reflect on how their model may be mobilised for political aims in a manner that has adverse consequences (Palmer 2017). This is particularly pertinent for the work presented here which deals with sensitive issues, such as migration in an abstract manner, devoid of the human context.…”