Beyond multination federalism: Reflections on nations and nationalism in Canada

Abstract

This article addresses the problem of managing nationalism in multination states by evaluating the influential multination federal model, as put forward by a group of Canadian scholars. Finding that it employs an overly primordial view of nations, the article argues that John Hutchinson’s approach, which foregrounds the conflict of nationalisms that occurs within nations, offers a better lens from which to bring to light the sources of unity and disunity in multination states. To illustrate this, the article discusses the conflict of nationalisms in Canada, suggesting that a debate over the merits of pan-Canadian nationalism within English Canada and French Québec can be identified. In failing to account for this, the article argues that the multination federal model risks (1) marginalizing French-speaking Quebecers who support pan-Canadian nationalism and (2) encouraging English Canadian nationalism. To conclude, the article suggests that models seeking to mitigate the potential centrifugal effects of nationalism should avoid privileging one type of nationalism over another.

Civilizing Model Tests of Four Pillars of Nationality To Build Nationalism for Students Towards Indonesian Generation 2025

“…John Hutchinson's approach, behind the background of the conflict of nationalism, offers a better lens as a source of multi-nation unity. The findings of this article that the federal multi-nation model marginalizes Quebecers in favor of pan-Canadian nationalism and can reduce the centrifugal impact of nationalism and avoid privileging one type of nationalism over another [21]. In line with the study of liberal nationalism and cultural rights.…”

The Life and Death of an Issue: Canadian Political Science and Quebec Politics

“…Multinationalism reflects the presence of what Kenneth McRoberts has described as internal nations, made manifest by the presence of the Quebec nation, but also of Indigenous peoples and, to some extent, Acadians (McRoberts, 2001, 2019). It does, however, raise a number of problems, including the reification of so-called national groups (Schertzer and Woods, 2011; Woods, 2012). Moreover, the struggles led by these internal nations jeopardize the pan-Canadianism to which a majority of English Canadians subscribe.…”