Beyond Ideology: Epistemological Foundations of Vladimir Fock's approach to Quantum Theory

Abstract

Vladimir Fock was a Soviet theoretical physicist who, from the 1930s, worked to prove that modern physics was compatible with the Marxist philosophy of dialectical materialism. In 1957, he went to Copenhagen, and a dispute over the interpretation of quantum mechanics began with Niels Bohr. Fock later claimed that he had found points of convergence with his Danish colleague, most of them concerning issues of wording and recognition of the reality of the world independently of our mind. It led to a specific narrative among historians of physics on Fock and his interpretation of quantum mechanics: The Soviet physicist is often described as a member of the Copenhagen school that contributed to the rapprochement of the Soviet philosophy of physics with the ideas of complementarity in stripping away the positivism in its formulation. Our contribution aims to show that this ideological dimension was only one aspect of reality. Returning to the foundations of Fock's epistemology of physics, we argue that he relied on the principles of antireductionism and scientific realism to develop an interpretation of the theory that sought to overcome Bohr's approach and that the differences between the two men cannot be reduced to mere questions of formulation.

Universal Constants as Manifestations of Relativity

“…At the same time, a similar discussion occurred between leading Western scientists; the leading role in it was played by Niels Bohr [7]. The disagreement with some of the Bohr's views on the QM [8] led Fock to the long debate with him (a detailed comparison of the epistemological positions of Fock and Bohr can be found in [9]). .…”