Beyond Competencies: Associations between Personality and School Grades Are Largely Independent of Subject-Specific and General Cognitive Competencies

Abstract

The Big Five personality traits are established predictors of school grades. However, the mechanisms underlying these associations are not yet well understood. Effects of personality on grades might arise because behavioral tendencies facilitate learning and increase subject-specific competencies. Alternatively, personality effects on grades might be independent of cognitive competencies and reflect otherwise valued behaviors or teachers’ grading practices. In the current study, we drew on large-scale data of 7th and 9th graders in Germany to explore the extent to which personality predicted grades even after accounting for competencies. Controlling for competencies and other key covariates, we cross-sectionally and longitudinally examined personality–grade associations across different school subjects, grade levels, and school types. Results indicate that the predictive power of personality is largely independent of subject-specific and general cognitive competencies. The largest effects emerged for conscientiousness. For openness, associations with grades partly overlapped with competencies, suggesting that openness may operate by fostering competencies. Overall, our results suggest that the associations between personality and grades unfold mostly independently of course mastery. This finding underlines the socioemotional value of personality in the classroom and encourages a more fine-grained view of the interplay between personality, competencies, classroom behavior, and grades.

The Big Five Personality Dimensions in Large-Scale Surveys: An Overview of 25 German Data Sets for Personality Research

“…On the other hand, the available longitudinal data allow researchers to predict outcomes based on previously assessed personality structure (e.g., COVID-19-related attitudes and behavior; Rammstedt et al, 2021) in order to investigate personality change based on repeated Big Five assessments (Lucas & Donnellan, 2011; Roemer et al, n.d.; Specht et al, 2011) and to draw stronger causal inferences (e.g., Anger et al, 2017; Sander et al, 2021).…”

Open Peer Commentary and Author Response Regarding ‘Life Events and Personality Change: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis’

“…Recent empirical work that assessed attachment (Fraley et al, 2021) and Big Five personality states monthly (Dugan et al, 2023) over two years demonstrates that elastic and pliable trait change trajectories in reaction to naturally occurring life events can be empirically distinguished. The contribution of both elastic and pliable month-to-month trajectories to longer-term cumulative trait change across the lifespan is an open question for the next generation of personality development research to address (Roemer et al, under review).…”

Development of a Scale for Measuring the Competencies of Islamic Counselors

“…Counselors are expected to serve as role models for their clients (Zaini & Nita, 2017). Muslim counselors possess Islamic personality competencies that distinguish them from other counselors who do not adhere to eastern ethical principles (Riswanto et al, 2016). The secular Western culture of character development does not require belief in God, and personality is viewed only as the ability to follow a code of ethics during counseling services (Othman et al, 2014;Szilagyi & Paredes, 2010).…”