Beware of white matter hyperintensities causing systematic errors in FreeSurfer gray matter segmentations!

Abstract

Volumetric estimates of subcortical and cortical structures, extracted from T1‐weighted MRIs, are widely used in many clinical and research applications. Here, we investigate the impact of the presence of white matter hyperintensities (WMHs) on FreeSurfer gray matter (GM) structure volumes and its possible bias on functional relationships. T1‐weighted images from 1,077 participants (4,321 timepoints) from the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative were processed with FreeSurfer version 6.0.0. WMHs were segmented using a previously validated algorithm on either T2‐weighted or Fluid‐attenuated inversion recovery images. Mixed‐effects models were used to assess the relationships between overlapping WMHs and GM structure volumes and overall WMH burden, as well as to investigate whether such overlaps impact associations with age, diagnosis, and cognitive performance. Participants with higher WMH volumes had higher overlaps with GM volumes of bilateral caudate, cerebral cortex, putamen, thalamus, pallidum, and accumbens areas (p < .0001). When not corrected for WMHs, caudate volumes increased with age (p < .0001) and were not different between cognitively healthy individuals and age‐matched probable Alzheimer's disease patients. After correcting for WMHs, caudate volumes decreased with age (p < .0001), and Alzheimer's disease patients had lower caudate volumes than cognitively healthy individuals (p < .01). Uncorrected caudate volume was not associated with ADAS13 scores, whereas corrected lower caudate volumes were significantly associated with poorer cognitive performance (p < .0001). Presence of WMHs leads to systematic inaccuracies in GM segmentations, particularly for the caudate, which can also change clinical associations. While specifically measured for the Freesurfer toolkit, this problem likely affects other algorithms.

Brain aging and cardiovascular factors in HIV: a longitudinal volume and shape MRI study

“…In addition, T2 FLAIR white matter hyperintensities were determined using a fully convoluted neural network, which was the top-ranking method in a recent multiscanner challenge [26] and manually checked for accuracy. These white matter hyperintensities were subtracted from the Freesurfer subcortical volumes as they are known to artificially inflate volumes [27]. Adjusted volumes were used for all subsequent analyses.…”

vol2Brain: A New Online Pipeline for Whole Brain MRI Analysis

“…One of the objectives of the proposed method was to be able to deal with images with white mater lesions. This is fundamental, as if we do not take into account those regions, they are normally misclassified as a cGM or sGM (which also affects the cortical thickness estimation) (Dadar et al, 2021 ). The results of WM lesion segmentation are summarized in Table 3 (left and right lesions were considered together).…”

Using Transfer Learning for Automated Microbleed Segmentation

“…The final segmentation output (aseg.mgz) was then used to obtain individual masks for cortical GM, deep GM, cerebellar GM, WM, and cerebellar WM based on the FreeSurfer look up table available at https://surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/fswiki/FsTutorial/AnatomicalROI/FreeSurferColorLUT. Since FreeSurfer tends to segment some WMHs as GM (Dadar et al, 2021c), we also segmented the WMHs using a previously validated automated method (Dadar et al, 2017b, 2017a) and used them to correct the tissue masks (i.e. WMH voxels that were segmented as cortical GM or deep GM by FreeSurfer were relabelled as WM, and WMH voxels that were segmented as cerebellar GM by FreeSurfer were relabelled as cerebellar WM).…”