Between “ethnocide” and “genocide”: violence and Otherness in the coverage of the Afghanistan and Chechnya wars

Abstract

The Soviet occupation of Afghanistan and the two Russian wars in Chechnya were the longest, most protracted conflicts of the USSR and Russia after WWII. Both were conducted under conditions of unprecedented violence in peripheral territories. Despite their distance in time and space, both wars are closely linked to each other on the level of cultural representations in contemporary Russia. This paper analyses how the conflicts were represented in a key Soviet and Russian newspaper as the wars unfolded. It analyses the textual and visual coverage of the wars in the Krasnaia zvezda (1980-1986; 2000-2003), in order to disclose changing interpretations of violence and the Other. The paper argues, firstly, that Krasnaia zvezda told the story of two different types of violence prevailing in each conflict. The Afghan case was presented as one that put the social and cultural transformation of the population at the center of its attention-violence was hence not only physical and excessive but also cultural, as it aimed at the social fabric of society. The Chechen case focused on the recapture of territory and the restoration of sovereignty. Therefore, physical violence appeared more bluntly in the coverage of the conflict. Secondly, the paper shows that these two different types of violence implied two different visions of the Other. In Afghanistan, the Other was represented as becoming more and more similar to the socialist Self. This dynamic is visually underscored by numerous images of Afghans who have embarked on the path to Soviet modernity. In Chechnya, in contrast, the Other was presented as traditional, backward, and immutable. The Other was usually reduced to complete cultural difference and depicted a dehumanized fashion. This orientalization of the Other was a precondition for the use of excessive physical violence.

La propaganda como termómetro de la lucha armada: el caso del Emirato del Cáucaso (2010-2019)

“…Aterrizando en el Cáucaso norte, las principales publicaciones sobre comunicación y terrorismo se han enfocado en describir los imaginarios sociales reproducidos por los medios tradicionales, ya fuese en la Primera Guerra de Chechenia (Clogg 1997;Kagarlitskii 1998) o en la Segunda (Petersson 2008;Casula 2015). Fundamentalmente, se han referido a cómo, desde Rusia, se han reproducido diferentes estereotipos arraigados en la historia -salvajis-3 Analizar la propaganda terrorista también ha permitido entender los aspectos psicológicos que establecen los militantes con sus audiencias (Houck, Repke y Conway III 2017); las compatibilidades ideológicas entre grupos armados diferentes (Chiluwa 2017); el reconocimiento de identidades colectivas entre organizaciones y simpatizantes (Torres-Soriano, Jordán y Horsburgh 2006); cómo algunas insurgencias estructuran sus unidades de comunicación de forma similar a las empresas (Wilbur 2017); identificar tácticas de reclutamiento (Mahood y Rane 2017) y generar contranarrativas para combatir la violencia (Andre 2012).…”

Communicative ethnocide and Alevi television in the Turkish context

“…Lemkin (cited in Clavero, 2008), who coined the term genocide, has suggested that the term ethnocide can also be used as a synonym and in legal studies ethnocide often refers to cultural genocide and the cultural destruction of indigenous cultures (Clavero, 2008). In the 1970s, it was particularly used in relation to indigenous cultures in the Americas (Barabas and Bartholeme, 1973; Escobar, 1989; Lizot, 1976; Venkateswar, 2004), although later the concept has been used to explain the cultural destruction of different communities living in different countries (Casula, 2015; Clarke, 2001; Lemarchand, 1994; Williams, 2002). A report by the United Nations on the genocide of indigenous populations refers to ethnocide as follows:In cases where such [state] measures can be described as acts committed for the deliberate purpose of eliminating the culture of a group by systematically destructive and obstructive action, they could be deemed to constitute clear cases of ethnocide or cultural genocide.…”

Civil Population Of Chechen Republic In "Counter-Terrorist Operation"

“…Different data was mentioned on this issue: 12000 missing people, about 3000 people in incomplete lists of the Memorial Human Rights Center. By December 1, 2001, 793 unsolved cases of missing people were registered with the Office of the Special Representative for Human Rights (Casula, 2015).…”